In November 2011, 33-year-old Florida mother Michelle Parker disappeared on the same day an episode of The People’s Court aired featuring a dispute with her former fiancé, Dale Smith Jr. For nearly 15 years, investigators searched for answers, but Michelle’s body was never recovered. In October 2026, Orlando police arrested Smith and charged him with second-degree murder following a renewed investigation that included a review of digital evidence. This episode examines the disappearance, the unusual television connection, and how investigators can build a homicide case even when the victim’s remains have never been found.

The Woman Who Vanished After Appearing on The People’s Court

In 1962, Charles Hale and Lester McCollum were murdered near Battle Ground, Washington, leaving investigators with a mystery that would remain unresolved for more than six decades. Despite the passage of time, two seemingly insignificant pieces of evidence, cigarette butts and twine, would eventually help investigators identify two suspects. In October 2026, the Clark County Sheriff’s Office announced that modern DNA analysis pointed to Barton Stebbins and Walter Stain, both teenagers at the time of the murders. This episode examines how forensic technology brought new answers to a 64-year-old double homicide and why the suspects will never face trial.

The Cigarette Butts That Solved a 64-Year-Old Double Murder

When remains are too badly damaged for visual identification — burned, skeletonized, or decomposed beyond recognition — the work of putting a name to them falls to forensic anthropology. This episode examines how specialists reconstruct identity from what little is left: estimating age, sex, and stature from bone structure, and extracting usable DNA from material that fire or time has severely compromised. We look at how dental records and forensic odontology provide another critical point of comparison when bones alone can’t tell the full story. Finally, we explore why matching unidentified remains to missing-person databases remains one of the most persistent challenges in forensic science, from incomplete records to the sheer scale of unsolved cases nationwide.

The Evidence Left Behind: Can Forensic Science Identify Mexico's Missing?

MAN SENTENCED TO LIFE FOR A 40 YEAR OLD COLD CASE MURDER

TEXAS NURSE COLD CASE MURDER SOLVED AFTER 40 YEARS

COLD CASE ARREST CULMINATES DECADES OF WORK IN HOMICIDE CASE

COLD CASE OF BROTHER AND SISTER MURDER HAS BEEN SOLVED AFTER 34 YEARS

30 DOUBLE HOMICIDE CASE SOLVED BY FBI WITH DNA AND SOME LEGWORK

20 YEAR OLD HOMICIDE COLD CASE SUSPECT ARRESTED1

2006 MURDER COLD CASE SOLVED

COLD CASE MURDER OF38 YEARS KILLER ARRESTED AND NOW LINK HIM TO POSSIBLY ANOTHER COLD CASE

A COLLEGE STUDENT WAS MURDERED 48 YEARS AGO AND NOW THE CASE HAS BEEN SOLVED

43 YEAR OLD COLD CASE MURDER SUSPECT ARRESTED THANKS TO DNA

True Crime

COLD CASES SOLVED

Share COLD CASES SOLVED

Sign up to save your podcasts

COLD CASES SOLVED

COLD CASES SOLVED episodes

More shows like COLD CASES SOLVED

20/20

48 Hours

Snapped: Women Who Murder

Cold Case Files

Crime Junkie

Morbid

Dateline NBC

I Survived

Park Predators

Anatomy of Murder

The Deck

True Crime with Kendall Rae

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries

Murder: True Crime Stories