On April 15th, 2012, 15-year-old Chelsea Johnson was found brutally stabbed to death in a shallow creek near the apartment she shared with her mother in Fairfield, Ohio. The crime scene, compromised by water and exposure, offered little in the way of physical evidence. With mounting public pressure and no clear suspect, investigators quickly arrested a local man, but the arrest lacked solid evidence, and charges were later dropped. Over a decade has passed, and the case remains unsolved. Chelsea’s family is still left with more questions than answers. In this episode, we revisit the case that’s haunted a community for over ten years, in search of the truth behind Chelsea Johnson’s murder.

In June 2021, 47-year-old James Valdez left his home after a heated argument with his wife. Days later, his vehicle was found abandoned near a secluded swimming hole in Sugar Grove, Arkansas—with the engine dismantled, his personal belongings missing, and a chilling message scrawled on the back window.

James hasn’t been seen since.

In this episode, we dive into the timeline, conflicting witness accounts, strange discoveries, and the many unanswered questions surrounding his case.

On July 6, 2019, 25-year-old Chance Englebert vanished without a trace in Gering, Nebraska. After an argument with his in-laws, Chance left on foot around 7:00 PM. 

Despite extensive searches, no trace of Chance has ever been found. Suspicious details, including doorbell footage of a man resembling him getting into a car and his wife inquiring about a death certificate just days later, have only deepened the mystery.

His family is still searching for answers. A $220,000 reward is being offered for information leading to his whereabouts.

In this episode we’re diving into some big updates in three major cases we have covered: the shocking murder of Thomas and Angela Strussion, the long-awaited developments in the Delphi Murders, and the latest legal twists in the Idaho College Murders. We’ll break down new evidence, legal proceedings, and what these updates mean for the families awaiting closure.

On January 23, 1999, two-year-old Teekah Lewis vanished from the New Frontier Bowling Alley in Tacoma, WA. Despite a massive search and ongoing investigations, she has never been found. Witnesses reported seeing a maroon Pontiac Grand Am speeding away that night, and a suspicious man with a history of attempted abductions was seen at the alley.

Teekah’s family has never given up hope. If you have ANY information, no matter how small, please come forward. Help bring answers to her family.

On a quiet Sunday morning, September 5th, 1982, 12-year-old Johnny Gosch vanished while delivering newspapers in West Des Moines, Iowa. His abandoned wagon, still filled with papers, was the only trace left behind. Convinced their son was abducted, Noreen and John Gosch fought tirelessly to uncover the truth, facing indifference from law enforcement and a case that grew colder by the day. Refusing to let Johnny be forgotten, they pushed his story into the national spotlight—making him one of the first missing children featured on milk cartons. Over four decades later, chilling theories, cryptic sightings, and unanswered questions continue to haunt true crime enthusiasts. What really happened to Johnny Gosch? And could he still be out there?

On October 15, 2018, 13-year-old Jayme Closs was abducted from her home in Barron, Wisconsin, after her parents were brutally murdered. The suspect, Jake Patterson, had meticulously planned the crime after spotting Jayme by chance. For 88 long days, Jayme was held captive until she miraculously escaped. Jayme’s story is one of unimaginable tragedy and incredible survival.

The Cook brothers, Anthony and Nathaniel, terrorized Toledo, Ohio, from the late 1970s to the early 1980s. Together, they committed a string of brutal crimes, including murders, rapes, and violent assaults. Their victims ranged from young couples to a 12-year-old girl. Despite the chaos they left behind, the brothers evaded full justice until 1998 when advancements in DNA technology linked them to multiple unsolved cases.

30 year old, Mica Miller, was found dead on April 27 at Lumber River State Park in North Carolina. Her death was ruled a suicide, but troubling allegations have surfaced. From claims of abuse by her estranged husband to disturbing incidents like tracking devices and deflated tires, Mica’s story paints a picture of a woman living in fear.

Her family and attorney are now raising questions about the investigation, while her community rallies for answers.