In July of 1986, a grisly discovery was made in a cabin on Lake Michigan when an entire family was found murdered. Join Ericka and Abby as they discuss this case and the suspects accused of this seemingly unprovoked crime. 

Sources:

Huwe Burton arrived home from school in 1989 to find things out of place - it was later that evening that he discovered his mother had actually been murdered. Police immediately suspected Huwe of the murder and charged him with a crime that he didn't commit.

Sources:

When Marlene Warren answered the door at her home in 1990 thinking she was receiving a gift, she was tragically shot and killed. Decades later, the case finally saw some closure - but many doubts still remain. 

Sources:

Claudia Lawrence went missing from Yorkshire in March of 2009. Police had very little to go off of with her disappearance, and her case is still unsolved to this day.

Sources:

After a traffic stop in Canada, officers make a grisly discovery. One that would possibly lead to the identification of one of Canada's youngest serial killers.

Sources:

In 1977 residents of Circleville began receiving letters addressed to their home that contained private information. Some of these letters were more aggressive and invasive than others. These letters eventually caused one death and came close to causing a second. But who wrote them? Listen to this episode to hear about the letters that terrorized this small town in Ohio.

Sources:

30-year-old Joan Risch mysteriously disappeared from her home in Massachusetts, leaving behind a bloody crime scene. Listen in as Abby and Ericka discuss her case and present the many theories of what happened to Joan.

Sources:

Branson Perry went missing from his home in 2001 after going out to the barn to return something. There are multiple things about his case that don't add up. Listen to this episode as Ericka and Abby tell you about this mysterious and unsolved disappearance. Sources:

The cold case of Deborah Sheppard led to a shocking discovery over 25 years after her murder. Join Ericka and Abby as they unfold this case of twists and turns. 

Sources:

In 1977 26-year-old Sister Roberta Elam decided to pursue her dream of becoming a nun. During one of her normal prayer times at the convent, she was brutally attacked and murdered. Her murder had multiple suspects but 46 years later, there are still no answers. Sources: