In 1961, multiple deaths upon the Bluebelle Ship lead to a case with twists and turns, leading to the discovery that one of the members may be hiding the truth. Join Abby and Ericka as they unpack this case full of mystery. 

Sources:

In November of 2010, Howard, Ohio police were called for a welfare check after Tina Hermann did not show up for work. What they found was a horrific scene that left many questions about what had happened there.

Sources: 

The long unfolding case surrounding the murders linked to Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell continues to unfold as one of the most bizarre true crime cases of the century. Join Abby and Ericka as they discuss this case in a multi-part series.

Sources:

The long unfolding case surrounding the murders linked to Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell continues to unfold as one of the most bizarre true crime cases of the century. Join Abby and Ericka as they discuss this case in a three part series.

Sources:

The long unfolding case surrounding the murders linked to Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell continues to unfold as one of the most bizarre true crime cases of the century. Join Abby and Ericka as they discuss this case in a three part series.

Sources:

In June of 1992, 3 women went missing from Springfield, Missouri. These women were never seen or heard from again. Listen to this episode to hear their story!

Sources:

To provide or request additional information, please contact:
- Lt. Bryan Welch, Springfield Police Department, MO, (417) 864-1751, [email protected] - FBI ViCAP, (800) 634-4097, [email protected] 

Sarah Ware

Sarah MacDonald Ware was brutally murdered in 1898. This over-a-century-old case still remains unsolved. 

Sources:

Cherrie Mahan 

Cherrie Mahon was the first child to be featured in the ADVO "Have You Seen Me?" program after she went missing in 1985. She hasn't been seen or heard from since that day.

Sources:

In the early 1900's Nancy Doss was given the nickname giggling granny after she was found to have done some horrific things. Listen to this 2-part series to hear about the crimes she committed.

Sources:

In the early 1900's Nancy Doss was given the nickname giggling granny after she was found to have done some horrific things. Listen to this 2-part series to hear about the crimes she committed.

Sources:

A robbery in 2000 led to the arrest of an Ohio man. However, 21 years later, questions arise on whether police have the right man.

Sources: