Crimes & Closets

Crimes & Closets

By Cristy & BethTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Crimes & Closets episodes

  • Covid Conspiracy: The Gretchen Anthony Story
    After missing work in March of 2020, Gretchen began sending text messages to family and friends stating she was very ill and being hospitalized with COVID-19. The texts were suspicious in nature and caused concern for her loved ones so they reached out to police. Based on evidence found at the local hospital, Gretchen's home, as well as the fact that her estranged husband, David, was missing, police went on a man hunt that spanned 1,900 miles away from their home in Florida. Law enforcement and Gretchen's family suspects that David murdered his ex-wife, disposed of her body in an unknown location(s), and sent text messages posing as Gretchen, claiming she was being quarantined and very sick with COVID-19. This unsolved case is relevant and scary and very 2020. Join us in the closet for the disappearance of Gretchen Anthony.
    ***If you have any information in the disappearance of Gretchen Anthony, you can contact the Jupiter Police Department at 561-741-2235.***
    Sources: People.com, ABCNews.go.com, PalmBeachPost.com, ABC7Chicago.com, NBCMIami.com, KNewz.com, WPFB.com
    37 min
  • Fort Worth Missing Trio
    Update from a family member: We had some facts a bit wrong. The girls apparently left around 11 am. Rachel’s dad is Raymond and Renee’s dad is Richard. Renee’s grandmother loved across the street from Rachel’s parents not Terry and Julie. She was not going to the party with Terry, it was just a family party. It was not a van that was seen but a gold sedan. **Three girls go shopping 2 days before Christmas and are never seen again.  What happened to these girls back in 1974.  If you have any information about this case please contact the Fort Worth Police Department at 817-469-8477.  Sources: charleyproject.org, wikipedia.com, medium.com, truecrimesociety.com, rcccmcc.com, missingtrio.com, reddit.com, nbcnews.com, youtube.com - Creepy News.
    43 min
  • Watch Your Step: The Story of Kathleen and Michael Peterson
    Kathleen Peterson was found by her husband, Michael, unconscious and bleeding to death at the base of the staircase. Was it a tragic fall down the stairs, a vicious owl attack that resulted in massive blood loss, or a calculated, or a copy-cat murder by the person she trusted most? These are the questions we will pose in the closet this week while we discuss the tragic, confusing, and unsettling case of Kathleen Peterson. Bring your drink and tell us what you think. 
    Sources: Oxygen - True Crime Buzz, Heavy.com, imdb.com, geneology.com, wiki2.org, radiopedia.org, wral.com, Netflix documentary: The Staircase (2005), Photo Credit: www.spotlightonlaw2.wordpress.com
    57 min
  • Bonus Episode: Q&A with Beth and Cristy

    Join us in our closets as we celebrate 2000 downloads with a special bonus episode.  We answer questions that listeners sent to us.  We had so much fun doing this! Thanks for the continued support.

    39 min
  • The Ice Box Murders
    Edwina and Fred Rogers lived near Houston, TX, with their son Charles. When a family member could not get ahold of them, they sent police to do a welfare check. What they find is unbelievable. Sources: heresthefuckingtwist.com, iceboxmurders.com, Texashillcountry.com, medium.com, truecrimetalestx.com, Wikipedia.com, mentalfloss.com, Chron.com, houstoniamag.com, houstonpress.com
    33 min
  • Lethal Lovers: Gwen Graham and Cathy Wood

    When psychologically disturbed Cathy Wood and Gwen Graham met and began a romantic relationship while working at a nursing home in Michigan, both ladies fell into a pattern of toxic, manipulative behavior that ultimately led Cathy to confess to 5 murders that the two of them had committed against the patients of Alpline Manor. We will try to untangle the lies, conspiracies, and questionable police methods and figure out who's story we believe. We'd love to hear from you too! Join us in the closet this week for an interesting tale of two lethal lovers.  Sources: Buzz Feed, Medium.com, exploreforensics.co.uk, murderpedia.org, people.com, ranker.com, Mayo Clinic, Crime Documentaries/Serial Killers Gwendolyn Graham and Cathy Wood (2019). Photo Credit: www.medium.com

    47 min
  • The Sodder Family Tragedy

    The Sodders were a well-respected Italian family in their town of Fayettville, WV.  They were happily married with 10 children.  Tragedy struck this family on Christmas Eve 1945 when a fire took the lives of 5 of the children, or did it?  Listen as this story takes twists and turns that you would never expect. Then decide for yourself if you think the children have perished. Sources : Historycollection.com, NPR.org, News.com.au, thoughtcatalog.com, truecrimefiles.com, wikipedia.org, smithsonianmag.com, West Virginia Crime Files Series: Volume 1 :  The Sodder Family Tragedy 

    43 min
  • Party Foul Play: The Kenneka Jenkins Story
    19 year old Kenneka and her friends attend a party in a hotel in the wealthy Chicago suburb of Rosemont when Kenneka soon goes missing and is found in vacant basement kitchen walk-in freezer. After hotel surveillance video and Facebook lives are reviewed and scrutinized, the family has more questions than answers and the public stands behind them. Is this a terrible tragedy? Or is it the perfect murder? Join us in the closet this week for the sad story and death of Kenneka Jenkins. 
    Sources: Chicago Tribune, ABC7 Eyewitness News, Atlanta News Now, Everipedia.org, Findagrave.com, WebMD, Mayo Clinic, MTV True Life:Crime "Tragic Accident or Calculated Murder?" 2020.
    49 min
  • The Mysterious Death of Nanette Krentel
    Nanette and Stephen were a happy couple living in Louisiana. A suspicious fire starts at the fire chief’s house and Nanette is found dead in the wreckage. Many mistakes during the investigation means we may never know exactly what happened to Nanette.  Sources:  wwltv.com, youtube.com, Louisiana Daily News. Photo Cred: Investigation Discovery
    36 min
  • The Disappearance of Riley Crossman
    A sweet, happy high school girl goes missing from a small West Virginia town without a trace. Only to be found over a week later with evidence and circumstances that shock a community almost beyond repair. This the tragic story of 15 year old Riley Crossman. 
    Sources: Oxygen Crime News, Heavy.com, 5WDTV-WV, Local WDMV.com, The Morgan Messenger, MorganCountyUSA.org, Websleuths, HeraldMailMedia.com, Facebook Group: Justice for Riley Crossman Discussion. If you would like more information on this case, or would like to follow along as the suspects trial proceeds, please follow the Facebook Group “Justice for Riley Crossman.”
    ---
    This episode is sponsored by
    · Anchor: The easiest way to make a podcast. https://anchor.fm/app
    41 min

About Crimes & Closets

From the publisher's feed

Just two moms hiding in our closets, drinking and talking true crime.

More shows like Crimes & Closets

Casefile True Crime by Casefile Presents

Casefile True Crime

37,555 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

112,250 Listeners

Crime Junkie by Audiochuck

Crime Junkie

368,995 Listeners

Morbid by Ash Kelley & Alaina Urquhart

Morbid

102,193 Listeners

Dateline NBC by NBC News

Dateline NBC

46,598 Listeners

True Crime with Kendall Rae by Mile Higher Media & Audioboom Studios

True Crime with Kendall Rae

6,684 Listeners