Critical Readings

Released on 2 March 2026:

The panel discusses chapters 30–39, with the unveiling of secrets including Edward and Lucy’s engagement, and Colonel Brandon’s connexion to Willoughby, and featuring a discussion of Colonel Brandon’s good character and Willoughby’s extravagant villainy.

Released on 23 February 2026:

The panel discusses chapters 18–29, with a omparison of the relationship of Elinore and Edward versus that of Marianne and Willoughby, a discussion of the role of leisure or industry in happiness, and a consideration of the failures of civility on show.

Released on 16 February 2026:

The panel discusses the first seventeen chapters of Sense and Sensibility, with special attention given to contemporary inheritance law, the character faults of the Dashwoods, and the opposition between Elinore’s ‘sense’ and her family’s ‘sensibility’.

Released on 9 February 2026:

The panel discusses Dr. Johnson’s imitation of the tenth satire of Juvenal, with its message of caution about advanced age and the temptations of academic life, with special attention given to the difference lying between imitation and translation.

Released on 2 February 2026:

The panel discusses the closing chapters—the battles against Smaug and between the five armies, and the journey home—with special attention to the influence of great wealth, the difference between leaders amongst the Lake-men, and Bilbo’s significance.

Released on 26 January 2026:

The panel discusses the party’s arrival in and departure from Lake-Town, and their arrival at and infiltration of the Lonely Mountain, with special attention to the contrast between rationalism and romanticism, particularly in the Master of Lake-Town.

Released on 19 January 2026:

The panel reads chapters 8 and 9, with special attention to the episodic structure of the narrative, the maturation of Bilbo and his rising stature amongst the dwarves, the role of hunger and darkness in creating tension, and the timeframe of events.

Released on 12 January 2026:

The panel discusses chapters 5–7, with examination of Tolkien’s sources and the chronology of its composition, discussion about the different phases of the story’s development, and a conversation about the chapter structure and roles of different races.

Released on 5 January 2026:

The panel discusses the first four chapters of The Hobbit with special attention to the development of the story as a text, its features connecting it to the genres of fairy tales and bedtime stories, and its careful use of narrative foreshadowing.

Released on 29 December 2025:

The panel closes out Romeo and Juliet, and the year 2025, with a discussion of Friar Laurence’s cowardly culpability, Romeo’s impassioned importunity, Juliet’s happy dagger, Paris’ finest hour, and Shakespeare’s interest in people of all walks of life.