The Mets head into the All-Star break with plenty to discuss, and we're breaking down everything from the organization's failures, top performances and everything in between.

This week, we dive into Zach Thornton's impressive showing before the break and what it could mean for the Mets' future. We also discuss the recent rumors surrounding Francisco Alvarez and whether New York should seriously entertain trade interest. Has Clay Holmes earned himself a contract extension? We examine what a new deal might look like and if the pro's outweigh a potential trade.

Plus, we put together some Luke Weaver mock trades, evaluate the Mets' 2026 MLB Draft class, and hand out our first-half player grades for the biggest names on the roster. Who exceeded expectations, who disappointed, and who has the most to prove after the break?

Join us for another packed episode featuring analysis, debate, trade talk, and everything Mets fans need heading into the unofficial second half of the season.

🔹 Zach Thornton's breakout performance before the All-Star break

🔹 Francisco Alvarez trade speculation

🔹 Should the Mets extend Clay Holmes?

🔹 Luke Weaver mock trade scenarios

🔹 Evaluating the Mets' 2026 MLB Draft haul

🔹 First-half player grades and second-half expectations

Be sure to like, subscribe, and leave a review if you enjoy the show. LGM!

**Recorded Prior to Home Run Derby**

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" at first purchase to get $20.00 off!

After weeks of frustration and mounting pressure, Steve Cohen has finally broken his silence on the state of the Mets. We break down everything the owner had to say, what it means for the remainder of the season, and whether fans should feel any more confident about the organization's direction.

With Carlos Mendoza out, the managerial search is already taking shape. We discuss the early candidates being linked to the job, who makes the most sense to lead the next era of Mets baseball, and what qualities David Stearns should prioritize in his next hire.

As the trade deadline approaches, reports indicate the Mets will be targeting the best possible prospect packages in return regardless of age, position or MLB readiness. We examine why the front office maintains this thought process and what that says about their long-term strategy.

Finally, we wrap up the episode with a pair of mock trades, exploring Freddy Peralta and Clay Holmes trade scenarios and what each player could yield on the market.

Don't forget to like, subscribe, and share the show with fellow Mets fans. Let's talk baseball!

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App & Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off!

The New York Mets have made sweeping changes, and we're breaking down everything from a chaotic week in Queens. Carlos Mendoza is out as manager, with Andy Green taking over on an interim basis. Was this the right move, or is Mendoza simply taking the fall for larger organizational issues?

We also take a hard look at David Stearns' tenure as President of Baseball Operations. Has his vision for the Mets lived up to expectations? What has he done well, where has he fallen short, and what comes next for the franchise?

Plus, we react to the Mets trading David Peterson to the Chicago Cubs, discuss the return package, what it means for the rotation moving forward, and whether more moves could be on the horizon.

Join us as we break down one of the most eventful weeks of the Mets season and discuss where the organization goes from here.

Follow us on INSTAGRAM, YOUTUBE & X: @cupofmets

Subscribe on SPOTIFY, APPLE or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

Download The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off!

The Mets open their series in Philadelphia with a big win, and we break down all the latest developments surrounding the club. Juan Soto continues his scorching stretch at the plate and now leads the National League with 169 wRC+.

We also discuss the encouraging news surrounding Francisco Lindor's impending return, Sean Manaea's impressive form since rejoining the rotation, why the starting staff may be better off moving forward without relying on Kodai Senga and how they can patch their five-man together.

Plus, we dive into the offense, bullpen, playoff outlook, and what this team needs to do to keep building momentum as the season rolls on.

Follow on INSTAGRAM, YOUTUBE & X: @cupofmets

Subscribe on SPOTIFY, APPLE or wherever you get your podcasts!

Download The SeatGeek App! USE CODE: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off!

**RECORDED PRIOR TO NEWS ON ALVAREZ RETURN & SENGA INJURY**

The Mets continue to steady the ship, winning seven of their last ten games and showing signs that this club may be turning a corner. In Episode 10 of Season 5, we break down what's fueling the recent stretch of success, the continued evolution of Carson Benge, and why veterans Bo Bichette and Marcus Semien finally appear to be finding their rhythm at the plate.

We also discuss Mark Vientos' ongoing struggles and whether the organization needs to start making difficult decisions as his disappointing season continues. Plus, we dive into the increasingly popular opener strategy, examine how the Mets are utilizing it, and share our thoughts on whether it's a sustainable approach moving forward.

All that and much more, including the latest roster storylines, player performances, and everything happening around the New York Mets.

Subscribe, download, and join the conversation! #LGM ⚾️🍎

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off

The vibes in Queens have officially hit rock bottom. In Episode 9 of Season 5, we break down another brutal stretch of baseball as the Mets continue spiraling with no signs of urgency or accountability from the top down. Is it finally time for David Stearns to wave the white flag and begin selling before the deadline frenzy begins?

We dive into the uncomfortable conversations surrounding the future of the franchise — including the unthinkable question: could Francisco Lindor actually be moved if this organization decides a full reset is necessary? Plus, frustrations boil over with the continued struggles of David Peterson and Mark Vientos, the lack of adjustments across the roster, and a clubhouse culture that feels completely stale.

The guys also sound off on Carlos Mendoza and why confidence in the manager may have officially evaporated. From lineup decisions to bullpen usage to the team’s overall lack of fire, nothing is off limits in one of the most heated episodes of the season.

All that and more on this episode of the podcast. LFGM… I guess

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off!

The New York Mets leave Washington with a split against the Washington Nationals and winners in 7 of their last 10, but was it a missed opportunity or a sign this team is beginning to find its identity? This week, we break down the series in DC, the continued emergence of the Mets’ youth movement, and why the young core is bringing much-needed energy to the roster.

We also dive into Bo Bichette starting to heat up at the plate and what his turnaround could mean for the lineup moving forward. Plus, with injuries, inconsistency, and workload concerns beginning to pile up, are the cracks in the starting rotation becoming a real issue? We discuss the biggest question marks surrounding the pitching staff, lineup construction, bullpen usage, and what needs to happen for the Mets to keep stacking wins heading into a crucial stretch of the season.

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off

The future may be arriving faster than expected in Queens. This week, we break down the growing impact of AJ Ewing and why his emergence is turning heads throughout the organization, while Carson Benge continues to heat up and make his case as one of the most exciting bats in the system.

We also dive into the ongoing frustration with over-managing through analytics and discuss why it may be time for the Mets to simply let the young players play through mistakes and develop naturally at the big league level. With injuries continuing to pile up across the roster, questions surrounding lineup construction, player usage, and organizational depth are becoming impossible to ignore.

Plus, we explore several hypothetical trade scenarios as the deadline slowly creeps closer — should the Mets buy, sell, or attempt to walk the line between both? Which veterans could become movable pieces, and what type of additions would actually make sense for the future of the organization?

All of that and more on this episode of the podcast!

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your favorite podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App - Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" to get $20.00 off!

The New York Mets continue their West Coast swing going 4-2, but not without some lingering frustrations. In this episode, we break down the bizarre series finale in Denver as the Mets appeared to punt the getaway game against the Colorado Rockies, raising plenty of questions about urgency, lineup construction, and in-game management.

We dive deep into Carlos Mendoza’s recent decision making, the bullpen usage that continues to confuse fans, and whether the Mets are overthinking matchups at the expense of consistency. Plus, are the constant lineup shuffles doing more harm than good for an already streaky offense?

And then there’s the elephant in the room: is it finally time for the Mets to DFA Sean Manaea? We discuss Manaea’s struggles, what the alternatives could be, and whether the organization is nearing a breaking point.

All that and more as we recap the road trip, examine the state of the roster, and look ahead to what’s next for the Mets.

FOLLOW on Instagram, YouTube & X: @cupofmets

SUBSCRIBE on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your podcasts!

DOWNLOAD The SeatGeek App! USE CODE: "CUPOFMETS" at first purchase to get $20.00 off!

The vibes in Queens are anything but steady right now. With injuries piling up across the roster and key contributors dropping left and right, the Mets are starting to look more like a MASH unit than a contender. Is this all setting the stage for Carlos Mendoza to take the fall? We dive into whether David Stearns could be lining up his manager as a scapegoat amid a spiraling situation that goes far beyond just the dugout.

Despite the chaos, the Mets did manage to take the opener against Washington—but even in victory, the same issues continue to linger. An offense that simply can’t deliver in big spots, lifeless at-bats, and a lack of identity at the plate are becoming the defining traits of this team. How much longer can this approach continue before real changes are made?

We break down the latest injuries, what it means for the roster moving forward, and whether there’s any realistic path to stabilizing things before the season slips away. Buckle up—because things feel like they’re heading toward a breaking point in Queens.

Follow on INSTAGRAM, YOUTUBE & X: @cupofmets

Subscribe on SPOTIFY, APPLE, OR WHEREVER YOU GET YOUR FAVORITE PODCASTS!

Download The SeatGeek App! Use Code: "CUPOFMETS" AT FIRST PURCHASE TO GET $20.00 OFF!