Finish It!

Ep. 336. Creeptobscare ’25: The Creature From Miller’s Pond Week 2

Listen Later

This week, Matt learns that the Creature is the least of their worries, Chris goes for quite a spin, and the Creeptobscare challenges continue! Are you prepared for multiple The Prestiges? Is anyone?!

https://archive.org/download/336-final/336%20final.mp3

Also, Chris challenges Matt to a User-generated round of the One Word Witch Quiz (thanks, Ty!), the guys randomly generate new friends in Let’s Roll a Dude: Secret Hal Edition, and you know things are gonna get banonzas!

Scroll down past the Let’s Roll a Dude tables to see the terrible pic Matt drew for this week’s Creeptobscare challenge!

Let’s roll A Dude: Secret Hal Edition

Your pal Hal seems like a normal kid, but he’s way more than meets the eye. When the poopy hits the fan, he becomes his true self!

– Matt

Grab a d6 and roll up your very own Hal!

  • Hal’s New Look
    • 1. Tron
    • 2. Robot suit (snail-shaped)
    • 3. Turns baseball cap backwards reeeal slow
    • 4. Full suit of armor riding a horse
    • 5. Exactly what Blade wears
    • 6. Becomes 6 feet tall
    • Hal’s Special Move
      • 1. Breakdance fighting
      • 2. +9 Charisma
      • 3. Wriggle through any hole
      • 4. Shapeshift into fart
      • 5. Found a genie lamp, one wish left
      • 6. Stare actual daggers
      • Hal’s Helpful Connection
        • 1. The mayor owes him one
        • 2. A talking, 700 lb horseshoe crab
        • 3. Rich cousin. Has a PS6 already somehow
        • 4. Sassy AI bicycle
        • 5. Guy who runs the arcade. He hears all the scuttlebutt.
        • 6. Ghost of Jacques Cousteau
        • Song that Plays in Everyone’s Head when Hal Walks in the Room
          • 1. Bad to the Bone
          • 2. We Built This City on Rock and Roll
          • 3. Sledgehammer
          • 4. Wipeout (Fat Boys version)
          • 5. Bust a Move
          • 6. Don’t Fear the Reaper
          • Hal’s Catchphrase
            • 1. I am not afraid of any ghosts!
            • 2. It’s lasagna time!
            • 3. There’s no time like go time!
            • 4. I’m bringin’ the party – the best friend party!
            • 5. Do you know who I am?!
            • 6. i’ve got your number now, pal (then says a random number)
            • Contents of Fanny Pack
              • 1. Lucky rabbits foot, mints
              • 2. Pile of cold sesame chicken (still good)
              • 3. Deck of cards for magic tricks
              • 4. Dimensional pocket, 3 string cheeses
              • 5. The actual Excalibur
              • 6. Throwing sand

                • Aaaaand here’s Matt’s drawing.

                Discord is so Hot Right Now

                Doing the Bluesky Thing

                Listen on Apple Podcasts

                Watch the YouTubes!

                We’re Still on Twitter

                Check Out the New Book and More!

                Merch Time: Creeptobscare Merch is Too Scary to Buy!

                We’re on Stitcher, Too

                There’s a Subreddit!

                Check Out Songs from the Musical and More on SoundCloud

                Catch up on Meanwhile in the Cave of Time, if You So Desire

                Illustration by Ted Enik

                ...more
                View all episodesView all episodes
                Download on the App Store
                Finish It!By Matt and Chris Yule
                • 5
                • 5
                • 5
                • 5
                • 5

                5

                102 ratings

                More shows like Finish It!

                View all
                How Did This Get Made? by Earwolf and Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, Jason Mantzoukas

                How Did This Get Made?

                23,202 Listeners

                Shmanners by Travis and Teresa McElroy

                Shmanners

                2,009 Listeners

                The Flop House by MaximumFun, Dan McCoy, Stuart Wellington, Elliott Kalan

                The Flop House

                4,449 Listeners

                My Brother, My Brother And Me by The McElroys

                My Brother, My Brother And Me

                30,120 Listeners

                Sawbones: A Marital Tour of Misguided Medicine by Justin McElroy, Dr. Sydnee McElroy

                Sawbones: A Marital Tour of Misguided Medicine

                14,847 Listeners

                The Adventure Zone by The McElroys

                The Adventure Zone

                35,614 Listeners

                Dear Hank & John by Complexly

                Dear Hank & John

                7,799 Listeners

                Good Job, Brain! by goodjobbrain.com

                Good Job, Brain!

                1,830 Listeners

                Escape This Podcast by Escape This Podcast

                Escape This Podcast

                339 Listeners

                Hey Riddle Riddle by Headgum

                Hey Riddle Riddle

                3,304 Listeners

                Dungeons and Daddies by Dungeons and Daddies

                Dungeons and Daddies

                10,245 Listeners

                Solve This Murder by solvethismurder

                Solve This Murder

                296 Listeners

                Let's Learn Everything! by Maximum Fun

                Let's Learn Everything!

                420 Listeners

                Lateral with Tom Scott by Tom Scott and David Bodycombe

                Lateral with Tom Scott

                484 Listeners

                Aurelius Whitlock's Murder Museum by Marcus Richardson and Nathan Hicken

                Aurelius Whitlock's Murder Museum

                83 Listeners