In the heart-wrenching premiere episode of "Trial and Error," unfold the events of one of Tennessee's most baffling and grim mysteries: the disappearance and murder of 20 year old nursing student Holly Bobo. A serene morning in a small town is shattered, sparking an emotional six-year journey involving relentless law enforcement, a tightly-knit community's hopes and fears, and numerous suspects. Dive into the enthralling investigation that entangles veteran U.S. Marshal John Walker, who is determined to challenge the convictions and search for the true culprit.

Join us as we explore the savage impact of drugs on this rural community, the prominence of media scrutiny, and the poignant toll on Holly's family. Through gripping interviews and expert storytelling, follow the intricate pathways of cell tower data, witness accounts, and the shattering revelations of insiders willing to unveil hidden truths. Discover the tireless pursuit of justice that compels seasoned lawyer Dana McLendon III and forensic neuropsychologist Dr. Katie Spirko to delve deeper into the case, determined to shine a light on questionable verdicts marking the end, or perhaps just the beginning, of this quest for truth.