Apologetics Profile

Episode 116: Dr. Tim McGrew on Miracles, David Hume and "Extraordinary Evidence" (Part 2)


Listen Later

Perhaps you have heard skeptics say that "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." What exactly does that mean? From where does it come? How can we as Christians intelligently respond to this claim when engaging our unbelieving friends and neighbors? 


On the second part of our discussion about David Hume with Christian philosopher Dr. Timothy McGrew, we unpack this popular phrase that Tim says is often "wielded like a talisman" in Christian/Atheist debates and discussions. We also unpack significant quotes from the second part of Hume's essay, Of Miracles. Tim provides more practical thought in how we can intelligently engage Hume and those who often cite him. 


ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

  • Watchman Fellowship's 4-page Profile on Atheism by Robert M. Bowman: watchman.org/Atheism
  • Watchman Fellowship's 4-page Profile on Scientism by and Luke Barnes and Daniel Ray: watchman.org/scientism
  • Watchman Fellowship's 4-page Profile on Street Epistemology by Daniel Ray: watchman.org/SE 
  • Tim McGrew Vs Peter Boghossian debate on the topic of Street Epistemology and the book, A Manual for Creating Atheists (YouTube):  http://bit.ly/TimMcGrew
  • Tim McGrew and atheist philosopher Graham Oppy discuss their book, Four Views on Christianity and Philosophy, at the Atheist & Christian Book Club (YouTube): https://youtu.be/2gGvCl4Kbbs
  • Additional Reading: Books mentioned in this episode include:

    • William Adam: An Essay in Answer to Mr. Hume's Essay on Miracles (Third Edition)
    • George Campbell: A Dissertation On Miracles: Containing an Examination of the Principles Advanced by David Hume in an Essay On Miracles
    • John Douglas: The Criterion ; Or, Rules by which the True Miracles Recorded in the New Testament are Distinguished from the Spurious Miracles of Pagans and Papists
    • Dr. Timothy McGrew is Professor and Chairman of the Department of Philosophy at Western Michigan University. He specializes in theory of knowledge, logic, probability theory, and the history and philosophy of science. He has published in numerous journals including Mind, The Monist, Analysis, Erkenntnis, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, and Philosophia Christi. His recent publications include the article on “Evidence” in The Routledge Companion to Epistemology, coauthorship of The Philosophy of Science: An Historical Anthology, coauthorship (with Lydia McGrew) of the article on “The Argument from Miracles” in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, and the article on “Miracles” for The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

      FREE: We are also offering a free subscription to our bimonthly Profiles here: www.watchman.org/Free

      SUPPORT: Help us create more content like this. Make a tax-deductible donation here: www.watchman.org/give.


      Apologetics Profile is a ministry of Watchman Fellowship
      For more information, visit www.watchman.org
      © Watchman Fellowship, Inc.


      ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store

      Apologetics ProfileBy James Walker

      • 4.9
      • 4.9
      • 4.9
      • 4.9
      • 4.9

      4.9

      41 ratings


      More shows like Apologetics Profile

      View all
      Reasonable Faith Podcast by William Lane Craig

      Reasonable Faith Podcast

      1,439 Listeners

      The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast by J. Warner Wallace

      The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast

      1,484 Listeners

      Unbelievable? by Premier Unbelievable?

      Unbelievable?

      2,026 Listeners

      Stand to Reason Weekly Podcast by Greg Koukl

      Stand to Reason Weekly Podcast

      1,228 Listeners

      Stand Up For The Truth Podcast by Stand Up For The Truth Podcast

      Stand Up For The Truth Podcast

      541 Listeners

      The AC Podcast by Apologetics Canada

      The AC Podcast

      177 Listeners

      #STRask by Stand to Reason

      #STRask

      577 Listeners

      The Alisa Childers Podcast by Alisa Childers

      The Alisa Childers Podcast

      5,217 Listeners

      I Don't Have Enough FAITH to Be an ATHEIST by Dr. Frank Turek

      I Don't Have Enough FAITH to Be an ATHEIST

      5,066 Listeners

      BibleThinker by Mike Winger

      BibleThinker

      2,731 Listeners

      The Remnant Radio's Podcast by The Remnant Radio

      The Remnant Radio's Podcast

      533 Listeners

      Cultish by Jeremiah Roberts, Andrew Soncrant

      Cultish

      3,527 Listeners

      Not By Works Ministries by J. B. Hixson

      Not By Works Ministries

      388 Listeners

      The Sean McDowell Show by Sean McDowell

      The Sean McDowell Show

      198 Listeners

      The Surprising Rebirth Of Belief In God by Justin Brierley

      The Surprising Rebirth Of Belief In God

      455 Listeners