After heroically grappling with the inscrutable temporal paradox created by having to go and watch the Netflix show in between Friends Forever discussions, our geniuses turn their great brains to the question of whether Cary Retlin is the coolest guy in Stoneybrook, why Cokie Mason has such a big house, and what, precisely, Mary Anne is evolving into. Then Tanner brings on a very special guest to attest to the fact that he is, and always has been, a nice boy.

Music credits:

“Revenge Dramatic Emotional Apocalypse,” by Luke PN

“Love Potion,” by Fasol Prod

“Stardust,” by Fox Beat Stock Music

Thanks as always to original Baby Boy Scott Lamb for the intro music, and to Cyril for the outro music.

Advertise on The Baby-Sitters Club Club via Gumball.fm

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices