Sal and BT take a call from a longtime Jets fan named Josh, who declares that after three decades of misery, he's "hanging them up" and is now a Bills fan. The hosts can't believe it, arguing that a true fan can't simply switch allegiances, especially not to a rival within the same division. They insist that the years of suffering are what make a fan's eventual payoff so sweet, and that by jumping to the Bills, Josh is not only abandoning his team but also giving up the chance to truly appreciate a future championship. Sal and BT argue that a person can't choose fandom, and that the years of emotional investment are not easily erased, even by the pain of endless losing.