In 1972, Nancy Trotter & Sue Wells were vacationing in Stuart, Florida when they met Gerard Shaefer, who offered to give them a ride to the beach. The plan for a quick drop off turned dark and this would be the beginning of a double life unveiled. Eventually, the double murder of Susan Place & Georgia Jessup would bring justice against this monster, but sadly there were many more victims that he never had to answer for.

Told By: Rachel

Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh

Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTube

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices