Amanda and Sarah look at the house hiders phenomenon, or, as they like to call it, Hinterkaifeck Syndrome™. Sarah covers the stalking case of Michelle Fredenburg-Onion and the delightful misadventures of Jeffrey Allen Manchester, AKA The Roofman. Amanda returns to Daniel LaPlante and keeps it local with a Pittsburgh tale before going into the super creepy story of the Spider Man of Denver. Other subjects covered include Buckcherry, bad Ghostbusters hygiene, and hard-partying squirrels.

Amanda and Sarah go under the sea with writer Alie Davis. Alie dives into her enthusiasm for mermaids and grapples with their history and meaning, from their more nefarious iterations to how they're portrayed in modern media. Other subjects covered include cryptid sex toys, Manatees: The Pugs of the Sea, and a brainstorming session for the perfect mermaid television series.

We're live, ghoulfriends! Amanda and Sarah record from Podcast Night at the Tolma with the abridged tale of The Demon of Brownsville Road. The ghouls take turns talking about Bob Cranmer, a former army officer and Pittsburgh political figure who insisted that he and his family were terrorized by a malevolent force in their Brentwood, PA home. The episode also includes personal ghost stories from fellow podcast hosts and audience members.

Amanda and Sarah welcome John Schalcosky, founder of The Odd, Mysterious & Fascinating History Of Pittsburgh (AKA Odd Pittsburgh), an in-depth, continuing exploration of the city's unusual, mysterious & forgotten history. John brings a wealth of strange stories about Pittsburgh, including a girl stricken by a demon, the bizarre namesake of the Allegheny River, and the possibly Satanic origins of Mt. Pleasant, as well as a few personal brushes with the paranormal.

Amanda and Sarah nerd out over their favorite mythological and folkloric creatures. Sarah goes into the many names and terrifying tales associated with the ominous Black Dog. Amanda gets all horse girl for the history of the unicorn and the differences between its Western and Eastern interpretations. Other topics covered include healing with horror movies, a patriotic fish podcast, and the delightful stupidity of Led Zeppelin lyrics.

Episode 02 guest Jess Turner returns to regale Amanda and Sarah with more chilling tales about messages from beyond, evil beings, and true crime. She begins with a few stories about her psychic relatives and a teenage friend with a demon problem. She also talks about her newfound fascination with the JonBenét Ramsey case, inspired by her move to Colorado. Other topics include a conspiracy theorist's dune buggy obsession, connecting with your ghoul-in-laws, and turning murder houses into B&Bs.

Amanda and Sarah ring in the New Year with cryptids, cults, and cool witch ladies. Sarah gives some love to the Italian epiphany folk heroine, La Befana, then moves on to the fascinating Old Christmas traditions of the Outer Banks and the myth of Old Buck. Amanda parties like it's New Year's Eve 1999 with a look back at the chaos and cults of Y2K and Project Megiddo.

Amanda and Sarah welcome guest Indigo Baloch of the Black Cat Market, the Mr. Roboto Project, The Honey Bee Review, and The Bite Zine. She tells a few harrowing stories, both personal and second hand, about hauntings at the Chatham University dorm Fickes Hall, as well as an emotional preteen message from beyond the grave. Other subjects covered include a leek theft, a Yuletide poem, an Aldi stalker, and a Pokemon fit for GxG.

Amanda and Sarah take an extra festive ride into the world of creepy, non-Krampus holiday creatures. Amanda kicks things off with Grýla, an Icelandic giantess believed to steal and eat naughty children around Christmastime. Sarah gives some insight to the 12 Days of Christmas and the many beliefs surrounding Hulda (AKA Frau Holle, Holda, Holla), a fascinating ancient Germanic deity associated with winter. Other subjects covered include hot holiday ghosts, Björk impressions, and tossing Mothman's salad.

Amanda and Sarah welcome guest Sarah Mary "Smellis" Ellis of the Pittsburgh punk band, Boiled Denim. She recounts a wealth of spooky experiences, from a truly creepy childhood encounter involving a bunk bed to a visit from a resident ghost at her former workplace, the Pittsburgh bar Spirit. Other subjects covered include a Count Chocula phobia, being way into Bill Murray, erotic fly fishing with Jeff Goldblum, and watching Meat Loaf die.