Amanda and Sarah take on cannibal cases from the 1940s to now. Sarah kicks it off with the jaw-dropping story of Leonarda Cianciulli, a serial killer dubbed "The Soap-Maker of Correggio" for the gruesome ways she disposed of her victims. Amanda details the very recent crimes of Natalia Baksheeva and Dmitry Baksheev, a married couple in Russia who claimed to have murdered and eaten 30 people, and Joe Metheny, a 1990s Baltimore serial who supposedly turned two people into barbeque.

Amanda and Sarah welcome guest Michael McBurney, an actor and improv comic who works with the Arcade Comedy Theater, Vigilance Theater Group, and Throughline Theatre Company. He discusses his obsession with the supernatural and paranormal and his own experiences with a creepy lucid dream, a spooky little sister, and a possibly haunted abandoned site called the Beverly Hills Hotel. Other subjects covered include the horrors of wax and waxing, the therapeutic qualities of bad TV, and a cool junior ghoul.

Amanda and Sarah finally discuss sex with ghosts! Sarah looks into the history of how incubi and succubi tricked people - including a German woman and a Pope - into having sex with them. Amanda returns to the present with Amanda Teague's spiritual marriage and ghost dick whisperer, Amethyst Realm, as well as the unfortunate tale of Ed Booker. Other subjects covered include a very weird dream, the shock of seeing your own vag, and the supernatural sexiness of Baywatch: Nights.

Warning: This episode begins with a discussion about the Tree of Life shooting in Pittsburgh. We understand that this topic might be too distressing for some listeners. If you are such a listener, please feel free to skip ahead to 13:18.

Guest Jamie Agnello talks about her family's ability to see the dead, including deceased relatives, a nun friend, and a little girl. Other subjects covered include a Dave Matthews alter ego, getting spooked by Ed and Lorraine Warren, and more Lily Dale stories.

It's the 25th episode! And to celebrate, Amanda and Sarah take fan-submitted questions and ask some of their own. They also reveal their own supernatural encounters, including a morning cereal scare and a hateful basement intruder. Other topics covered include the perils of dating monsters, Whoopi Goldberg's incredible dating history, and casting your own biopic, as well as a harrowing Halloween costume update.

Amanda and Sarah welcome Ian Riggins, a writer and personal trainer who shares a special connection with the Bunny Man. He details the many forms of the creepy Virginia urban legend - from a rabbit-mutilating mental patient to a hatchet-wielding misanthrope - and how it plays into him meeting his wife, Amanda. He and Sarah also discuss their holistic Wiccan fitness program, Magic Moves. Other subjects covered include Phoebe Judge impressions, fake 1990s food products, and a Muppets version of Ladyhawke.

Because there are no rules and everything is chaos, this episode is a grab bag! Amanda talks about the real-life strength ministry Power Team and scarecrow lore. Sarah gets behind osculum infame (or the Kiss of Shame), a supposed ritual where people greeted the Devil by kissing his butt. Other subjects covered include justifiably blaming stuff on your period, a funny spousal dream, and dirty fighting with Amazon purchases.

Amanda and Sarah welcome guest Laine Wooliscroft of the Cinema Psychos Show podcast. She talks all about being Wiccan and her spooky experiences with the spiritualist community Lily Dale, including an incredible reading by a grandmotherly medium. Other subjects covered include a crush confession, transforming into your perfect animal, and Halloween costume reveals.

Amanda and Sarah cover true crime with a supernatural twist. Amanda goes all the way back to the late 1800s with the tale of the Greenbrier Ghost, the only known conviction determined by testimony from beyond the grave. Sarah goes for a much more recent case by delving into the spooky and tragic details surrounding the mysterious deaths of the Jamison family. Other subjects covered include a creepy clown hallucination, obsessing over purse contents, and dream celeb podcast listeners.

Amanda and Sarah welcome guest Dakota Garilli, a writer, editor, and lit mag co-founder (IDK Magazine) with a few stories about his haunted New Jersey past. He talks about his dad's younger days living with an electric guitar-playing ghost on Mystic Island and recounts his own spooky experiences Ouija boarding in high school. Other subjects covered include sneaky World War I Germans, being hot for Wedgwood, and a little bit of butt stuff.