BT and Sal dive into the Yankees' colossal underachievement, declaring a loss to the Blue Jays in the series to be "absolutely, unequivocally unacceptable" and a "flat out failure," especially given the team's touted improvements and deep roster. They dissect the offensive struggles of the lineup, calling out players like Grisham and Chisholm for their postseason futility and poor approach at the plate, despite the team's elite regular-season performance. Shifting gears during their "Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth" segment, the conversation takes on wider sports and pop culture topics, including Giannis Antetokounmpo's trade rumors and potential fit with the Knicks, the season opener for the Rangers and their new coach, and a fiery take on Saquon Barkley's yardage projections and his recently aired grievances against the Giants organization. The show takes an unexpected turn as BT confesses he's become a "Swiftie," leading to a comical and relatable discussion on the realities—and "downhill" slide—of long-term marriage.