Susie and Nate dig into more of their coming out stories and then switch into a discussion on what it means to be Christian and gay and the attacks and doubts they've had to wrestle through.

While trying to form an attraction to women, Nate and Makenna were set up by leaders in their church, with not-so-great results. They reconnect 6 years later and we dig into both sides of the story for the first time.

Morgan, a good friend of Susie's, shares her coming out journey with Nate and Susie. Morgan was working for the church and leading in ministry when she realized she wasn't as straight as she thought she was.

Nate and Susie lighten the mood this week with some of their worst early dating stories. Plus their top dating tips for anyone who is newly out.

Susie's story of coming out as bi in her evangelical Christian community, where the church is her family. She shares the ups and downs of living in the tension of accepting herself and holding onto her faith.

Nate shares the story of his life as a gay, pastor's kid and shares his struggles with self-worth growing up, going to Bethel School of Ministry, working for Jesus Culture, and finally coming out as a gay Christian.

Welcome to the I Tried to Be Straight Podcast. Susie and Nate both grew up in the church and recently came out. They're here to share their stories and hear the stories of others. Join them as they dig into conversations about coming out, faith, and how they tried to be straight.