Today your hosts dive into the stories, debates, and bookish chaos currently dominating their BookTok For You Pages. From the internet’s obsession with the Heated Rivalry to the ongoing discourse around potential Gus casting for Beach Read, they break down what readers are loving, arguing about, and spiraling over online.

The trio also checks in on the latest buzz surrounding Red God and what fans are saying about updates from author Pierce Brown. Plus, Sunrise on the Reaping, Stephanie Garber, Project Hail Mary, and more. 

Along the way, they share the funniest takes, book adaptation soundtrack theories, and the bookish moments that had their group chat going off all week. If it’s trending on BookTok, chances are they’re talking about it.

Get ready for a rapid-fire tour through the internet’s favorite bookish rabbit holes—because this week, the FYP is running the show. 

Minky Couture blankets! Use code: READERS for 50% off

G2G Bar: Use code READERS for 15% off!

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

The friends take on a deceptively simple challenge: guess the book from its very first line.

It sounds easy… until it isn’t.

In this episode, Reggie, Kennedy, and Mikayla read famous opening lines from books they have collectively read to see if they can name the book before the clues run out. Some are instantly recognizable, others send them spiraling into wild guesses and questionable logic.

Play along and see how many you can get before they do!

Expect iconic openings, terrible guesses, and the occasional moment where someone actually knows the answer.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

Emergency bonus episode alert! The hosts drop everything to react to the internet-breaking interview between Call Her Daddy and Sarah J. Maas. They dive into the biggest moments from the interview, analyze every possible hint, and spiral (in the best way) over what it could mean for the future of the series.

From guessing whose POV the next book might follow to sharing their what color the next books will be, nothing is off the table. Expect excited tangents, questionable detective work, and plenty of “wait… what if?!” moments as they unpack it all in real time.

If you’re deep in the fandom and still processing the interview, this episode is basically your group chat in podcast form—full of speculation, hope, and excitement.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

Buckle up! Today your hosts are diving into James Islington's Heirarchy series for their winter book club. They're sharing their ratings, overall thoughts, and fan casts for The Will of the Many and The Strength of the Few. Which book was their favorite? What are their theories as to what happens next for Vis? Tune in to find out!

**SPOILERS FOR BOOK 2 IF YOU HAVEN'T STARTED/FINISHED YET AT 32:50**

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

After a little too much scrolling (and a lot of tempting recommendations), Reggie, Kennedy, and Mikayla are sharing the latest books they’ve added to their TBRs straight from Goodreads.

From new releases to backlist gems they somehow missed, they break down what caught their attention, why they couldn’t resist hitting “Want to Read,” and whether these picks will actually make it to the top of the pile. 

If your TBR is already out of control… consider this your official warning.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

The trio is sitting down for their third annual book dedication chat. Do you pay attention to the book dedications at the start of each book? If not, this episode will inspire you to. Join the gals as they shed a few tears over the most heartfelt dedications as well as share some laughs over the not-so-serious ones they've come across.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

In this delightfully chaotic episode, the trio bravely enters the battlefield of Goodreads: the one-star review section. Armed with strong opinions and absolutely no emotional preparation, they read the most unhinged, dramatic, and deeply personal attacks on their favorite books.

In this episode, nothing is safe. The gals dramatically reenact the harshest reviews, spiral over the audacity, and attempt to defend their beloved characters as if they personally know them (because, emotionally, they do).

Between gasps, cackling laughter, and mock outrage, they unpack the wildest takes the internet has to offer and reflect on the beautifully subjective chaos of reading. It’s petty. It’s passionate. It’s three best friends slightly losing their minds over strangers’ opinions.

Five stars for entertainment. One star for emotional stability.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

The girls are deep in their Windy City era and they’re not coming out anytime soon. In this episode, the trio dives headfirst into Liz Tomforde’s Windy City series, breaking down every book, every man, and every moment that had them crying and squealing. From star ratings and swoon-worthy moments to scenes that didn’t quite hit, nothing is off-limits.

They debate their favorite book from the series as well as their favorite FMCs and MMCs, defend their book boyfriends with their lives, and get a little (okay, very) passionate about which characters deserve the crown. Plus, they’re putting their casting director hats on with dream fan casts for each character.

Expect hot takes, unhinged fangirling, and lots of love for the Windy City men who set the standard way too high.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

The gal's most anticipated movie adaptation of People We Meet On Vacation has hit Netflix, and today, they are sharing all their thoughts on the book versus the movie. What did they rate the book? How did book Alex compare to movie Alex? What changes from the movie were they most upset with? Tune in to hear all their thoughts and what they are looking forward to seeing next from Emily Henry!

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON

It’s time to test the bookish hive mind. 
In this episode, the friends dive into Bookmark the Odds, the game where reader opinions rule and confidence is everything. After polling listeners with this-or-that and would-you-rather bookish questions, one host guesses the percentage—while the other two decide: higher or lower?

Points are scored, egos are bruised, and plenty of chaotic book talk fills the gaps. From Xaden vs. Rhysand to all the little reading habits readers love to argue about, this episode is pure bookish chaos, friendly competition, and way too many strong opinions.

Follow us on TikTok!

Follow us on Instagram!

Shop our merch: illreadwhatshesreading.com

SIGN UP FOR OUR PATREON