The Financial Independence Show

Index Funds vs. Stock Picking

Listen Later

In this episode, Cody and Justin discuss one of the most heated investing arguments.

Should you hand-select the “best” companies, or invest in the total stock market?

Some topics include:

  • Individual stocks are often investors’ first exposure to the stock market
  • The mental drag of stress from volatility
  • How individual stocks can scratch the itch
  • Setting non-negotiable limits
  • More certain path to FI vs the potential for a home run
  • Bad bets we’ve made on individual stocks

    • As part of this discussion, we compared several individual stocks against VTSAX.

    VTSAX is an index fund Vanguard offers and tracks the total stock market.

    List of stocks including present-day value and annualized return if you invested $1,000 on Aug 9, 2004, and reinvested dividends:

    • VTSAX
      • $5,807
      • 9.19% average annual return
        • Intel
          • $1,623
          • 2.45% average annual return
          • 7th Market Cap
            • Abercrombie and Fitch
              • $4,679
              • 8.02% average annual return
              • Couple of years after Hollister’s launch
                • Apple
                  • $396,562
                  • 34.85% average annual return
                  • Released iPod Mini
                  • If you bought on July 6, 1994 (Forrest Gump release date) -> $1.1M (26%)
                    • Coca Cola
                      • $6,007
                      • 9.37% average annual return
                      • Released C2
                        • General Electric
                          • $1,243
                          • 1.09% average annual return
                          • 5th Market Cap
                            • Wells Fargo
                              • $2,627
                              • 4.95%
                              • 15th largest market cap
                                • TI
                                  • $11,496
                                  • 12.98% average annual return
                                  • Year TI-89 was released
                                    • Sony
                                      • $2,691
                                      • 5.07% average annual return
                                      • PSP release date
                                        • Nokia
                                          • $730
                                          • -1.56% average annual return
                                          • 9 phone releases

                                            • We cover all of this and more.

                                            We hope you found value in the episode, if you did, subscribe, leave a review, and share with a friend!

                                            Links from The Episode
                                            • Stoculator
                                              • YouTube Interview

                                              https://youtu.be/0N4IlLBrYV0

                                              Join the Community

                                              We’d love to hear your comments and questions about this week’s episode. Here are some of the best ways to stay in touch and get involved in The FI Show community!

                                              1. Grab the Ultimate FI Spreadsheet
                                              2. Join our Facebook Group
                                              3. Leave us a voicemail
                                              4. Send an email to contact [at] TheFIshow [dot] com

                                                5. If you like what you hear, please subscribe and leave a rating/review!

                                                >> You can do that by clicking here <<

                                                Learn More About Your Hosts

                                                CodyDBerman.com (Cody’s Blog)

                                                Saving-Sherpa (Justin’s blog)

                                                ...more
                                                View all episodesView all episodes
                                                Download on the App Store
                                                The Financial Independence ShowBy Cody Berman and Justin Taylor
                                                • 4.8
                                                • 4.8
                                                • 4.8
                                                • 4.8
                                                • 4.8

                                                4.8

                                                296 ratings

                                                More shows like The Financial Independence Show

                                                View all
                                                Afford Anything | Make Smart Money Choices by Paula Pant, Personal Finance Expert | Cumulus Podcast Network

                                                Afford Anything | Make Smart Money Choices

                                                3,568 Listeners

                                                The Stacking Benjamins Show by StackingBenjamins.com | Money Podcast | Cumulus Podcast Network

                                                The Stacking Benjamins Show

                                                1,998 Listeners

                                                Financial Independence Podcast by The Mad Fientist

                                                Financial Independence Podcast

                                                1,645 Listeners

                                                Marriage Kids and Money: Personal Finance for Families by Andy Hill

                                                Marriage Kids and Money: Personal Finance for Families

                                                602 Listeners

                                                ChooseFI by ChooseFI

                                                ChooseFI

                                                5,152 Listeners

                                                Millionaires Unveiled by Jace Mattinson, CPA

                                                Millionaires Unveiled

                                                893 Listeners

                                                BiggerPockets Money Podcast by BiggerPockets

                                                BiggerPockets Money Podcast

                                                3,084 Listeners

                                                Earn & Invest by Jordan Grumet (Doc G)

                                                Earn & Invest

                                                452 Listeners

                                                The Personal Finance Podcast by Andrew Giancola

                                                The Personal Finance Podcast

                                                1,433 Listeners

                                                Risk Parity Radio by Frank Vasquez

                                                Risk Parity Radio

                                                281 Listeners

                                                Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors - The Best Interest by Jesse Cramer

                                                Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors - The Best Interest

                                                158 Listeners

                                                All the Hacks: Money, Points & Life by Chris Hutchins

                                                All the Hacks: Money, Points & Life

                                                1,618 Listeners

                                                Mile High FI Podcast by Doug Cunnington & Carl Jensen

                                                Mile High FI Podcast

                                                205 Listeners

                                                Catching Up to FI by Bill Yount & Jackie Cummings Koski

                                                Catching Up to FI

                                                356 Listeners

                                                Inside Out Money by Maggie Tucker

                                                Inside Out Money

                                                293 Listeners