In this episode of The Private Equity Podcast, Alex Rawlings speaks with Paul Isaac, Managing Partner of Isaac Management LLC, about investing in lower-middle-market businesses through a permanent-capital model.

Paul explains why Isaac Management operates without a traditional fund, predetermined exits or outside investor pressure. He discusses the risks of overleveraging, the importance of understanding a company’s community and culture, and why higher interest rates have created a disconnect between buyer expectations and seller valuations.

The conversation also explores Paul’s journey from banking and private credit to launching his own investment firm, how buyers can build trust with founders, and why operational improvement and talent development often create more sustainable value than financial engineering or acquisition-led growth.

Key Takeaways

• Why excessive leverage and weak market understanding can undermine an acquisition.
• How permanent capital supports patient ownership and long-term decision-making.
• Why lower-middle-market deal activity has slowed as financing costs have increased.
• How transparent communication and flexible deal structures can build seller trust.
• Why operations may offer a stronger value-creation opportunity than pricing or M&A.
• The importance of retaining, developing and incentivising key employees.

Timestamps

00:00 Paul’s background and the launch of Isaac Management
01:27 A permanent-capital approach without a traditional PE fund
02:24 The biggest acquisition mistake: overleveraging
04:50 Deal trends across the lower middle market
06:46 The valuation gap between buyers and sellers
08:39 Tariffs, financing costs and portfolio-company pressure
11:05 Chief Outsiders
12:32 Building an investment firm without institutional backing
15:28 From the search-fund concept to permanent capital
16:56 Why long-term ownership resonates with business founders
19:48 Lessons from seller conversations and dealmaking
21:18 Equity rollovers, seller financing and deal preparation
23:08 The most effective lower-middle-market growth lever
25:03 Talent retention and the true cost of replacing employees
26:31 Employee ownership and long-term engagement
27:00 Paul’s recommended media and publications
27:58 How to contact Paul Isaac

Raw Selection partners with Private Equity firms and their portfolio companies to secure exceptional executive talent. We focus on de-risking executive recruitment through meticulous search and selection processes, ensuring top-tier performance and long-term success.

🔗 Connect with Alex Rawlings on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/alexrawlings/
🌐 Visit Raw Selection www.raw-selection.com