This is going to be a two part series. This case is so insane we couldn't cover it all in one go.  This weeks episode we recap the HBO documentary Who Killed Garrett Phillips and dive into the death of Garrett Phillips and how the entire town of Potsdam railroaded an innocent black man.  Listen to how Nick Hillary is immediately deemed guilty by the court of public opinion. This case will drive you insane and have you screaming WHO KILLED GARRETT PHILLIPS?!?

Not much leaves Jeff speechless.. and this week ya'll, we did it.  This week we cover the HBO documentary Baby God and the INSANE story of Dr. Quincy Fortier.   Dr. Fortier spent YEARS heralded as one of the top fertility specialist in the United States.. but how did he obtain such accolades?  What made his couples experience the joy of pregnancy?  Listen to find out the true reason behind his success, and the evil that lived inside of him. 

Have you ever heard of Marta Erblinger? How about Albert Soleilland? Not many have but this case changed Parisian history.  The heinous death of Marta Erblinger moved the media at the time to stir the people of Paris in a frenzy to overturn the death penalty and put Albert Seoleilland to death.  Listen to the episode to see just how this all occurred, if law was changed, and what led to Alberts eventual death.   
 
 

On this week episode we explore the HBO Documentary Alabama Snake. The case is about Glenn and Darlene Summerford and what exactly happened one night in Scottsboro Alabama when Darlene Summerford called the police to report her husband had attempted to kill her by poisonous snake.  The case itself involves serpant handling, religion, sex, and attempted murder. ALLLLLL the ingredients for a wild true crime case. Listen and come up with your own theories of what happened to Darlene .  

It's the Merriest time of the year! Time for our first Christmas Episode!   Jeff is driving tranwreck this week covering the Devils of Dayton, four teenagers who went on a three day killing spree for NO APPARENT REASON. What was the motive --- Money? Lust? Drugs?   or just plain stupidity? Listen in and find out! 

This weeks episode is another Buffalo case, and another serial killer! The 22 caliber killer was tearing a part the city of Buffalo by killing African American men without any cause or reason splitting an already racially segregated city even further.  The Buffalo police were struggling to determine who the assailant was and eventually had to bring in the FBI to profile the case to begin to get an idea of exactly who this monster was..   Listen to find out the wild story of how this killer was eventually caught and justice was served. 

This week we tackle our first SERIAL KILLER!!  I know, ya'll have been waiting for this moment! We discuss another Buffalo case, the Bike Path Rapist.  The episode goes into his numerous victims, how he wasn't caught right away and how being a "pillar of the community" could lead police astray...   This case also led into another Buffalo exoneration!   Buckle up for a wild ride! 

On this week of It Just Makes Sense we'll be discussing the horribly sad story of the San Antonio Four and their fight for exoneration. This case takes on the idea of satanic panic, the discrimination of the LGBTQIA+ community and how true friendship can last behind bars and over many years.   Come join us on this wild ride! ...And find out why Sam is a ride or die Camila Parker Bowles fan.. 

On October 1st 1993, 12 year old Polly Klaas and two of her friends were having a fun filled girls night sleep over. Little did they know,  hours into the sleep over, and intruder would come in and kidnap Polly and leave the other two girls bound and gagged.  What turned into a nationwide man hunt for Polly's kidnapper, join us as we discuss the crazy kidnapping of Polly Klaas.    This one is wild ya'll!!