Canterbury Mornings with John MacDonald

John MacDonald: No Minister, this is not a win for democracy


Listen Later

How do you think I’m feeling about the Government's Māori wards bill passing its third reading in Parliament?  

Which means any local councils which established Māori wards without asking residents first will have to hold a referendum if they want to keep them. The same for any other councils that might want to in the future, as well.  

How do you think I’m feeling about that? I’m not feeling how Local Government Minister Simeon Brown is feeling. He’s saying today that it’s “a great day for democracy”. 

I don’t think that at all. I think he’s over-cooking that one, big time.  

I don’t feel the same way about it as Labour leader Chris Hipkins, either, who is saying that it’s “embarrassing”. 

But I am despairing, because this is a piece of legislation dealing with something that hurts no one. Having a Māori ward causes no harm to anyone. 

Now I know that some people think having a separate ward for Māori voters does cause some sort of harm. And normally they claim that it causes racial division. 

And, if they want to think that, then I can’t stop them. But I would ask anyone who thinks that: what harm does it do to you, personally? Does it make your life any worse? Does the idea of Māori wards make you less likely to get ahead in life? 

Does a Māori ward somewhere make the groceries, or the power, or registering the car more expensive? Does it make you more likely to get crook with a serious illness?  

The answer to all of those questions is “no”. But, somehow, some people think Māori wards are a threat to democracy. Which is nonsense.  

Because how can a constituency of people electing someone to be their representative on a council somewhere possibly be undemocratic? It’s not. 

Local Government Minister Simeon Brown is talking nonsense saying that forcing councils to have referendums before they can keep their Māori wards is a great day for democracy. 

It’s not about democracy, at all. In the Minister’s own words on radio this morning, it’s about being anti-woke. Whatever that is. 

It’s ideology and nothing else. Because Māori wards make no one’s life any worse - and getting rid of them won’t make anyone’s life any better. 

And they will fade out because we know who the people are who bother voting in local body elections - because these referendums are going to be done at the same time as local body elections. 

We know already, don’t we, what the results of these referendums are going to be because —generally— the people who can be bothered voting in their local council elections tend to sing from the same anti-woke songsheet as Simeon Brown. 

What’s more, if the Government is going to sell its Māori ward legislation as a win for democracy, and if councils are now going to have to ask ratepayers for permission before they can keep or set-up a Māori ward, then they should also have to ask for public permission to do anything else they want to do, as well. 

Now that would be democracy. But that’s not happening. Which is why it’s complete nonsense for the Government to claim that its crackdown on councils setting up Māori wards without asking for public approval first is a win for democracy. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Canterbury Mornings with John MacDonaldBy Newstalk ZB


More shows like Canterbury Mornings with John MacDonald

View all
Saturday Morning with Jack Tame by Newstalk ZB

Saturday Morning with Jack Tame

3 Listeners

Heather du Plessis-Allan Drive by Newstalk ZB

Heather du Plessis-Allan Drive

14 Listeners

The Mike Hosking Breakfast by Newstalk ZB

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

58 Listeners

Weekend Sport with Jason Pine by Newstalk ZB

Weekend Sport with Jason Pine

4 Listeners

Q+A by Q+A

Q+A

4 Listeners

The Weekend Collective by Newstalk ZB

The Weekend Collective

2 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

17 Listeners

The OneRoof Radio Show by Newstalk ZB

The OneRoof Radio Show

5 Listeners

Smart Money by Newstalk ZB

Smart Money

1 Listeners

Matt Heath & Tyler Adams Afternoons by Newstalk ZB

Matt Heath & Tyler Adams Afternoons

2 Listeners

A Captain's Cup by Radio Sport

A Captain's Cup

1 Listeners

The Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners

The Property Academy Podcast

28 Listeners

Newstalk ZB ANZAC Centenary Tribute by Newstalk ZB

Newstalk ZB ANZAC Centenary Tribute

0 Listeners

Sportstalk with D'Arcy Waldegrave by Newstalk ZB

Sportstalk with D'Arcy Waldegrave

0 Listeners

On The Front Foot by Newstalk ZB

On The Front Foot

5 Listeners

Holiday Breakfast by Newstalk ZB

Holiday Breakfast

0 Listeners

The Superior Sailor Series by Newstalk ZB

The Superior Sailor Series

0 Listeners

Rugby Direct by Newstalk ZB

Rugby Direct

4 Listeners

News Fix by Newstalk ZB

News Fix

0 Listeners

The Big League Podcast by Newstalk ZB

The Big League Podcast

2 Listeners

Election 2023: The Front Bench by Newstalk ZB

Election 2023: The Front Bench

0 Listeners

All Sport Breakfast Canterbury by NewstalkZB

All Sport Breakfast Canterbury

0 Listeners

Sports Fix by Newstalk ZB

Sports Fix

1 Listeners

Football Fever by Newstalk ZB

Football Fever

0 Listeners