In July of 2000, two young people in Indianapolis, Indiana were killed in a crime that would later be overshadowed by one of the most infamous prison escapes in the state’s history.

Andrew Cataldi and Tricia Nordman were complicated, imperfect, real people. Who made mistakes, but they were also more than the worst chapters of their pasts.

 Unfortunately, they were betrayed by the very people they trusted. Causing their murders to become tangled in the rise and fall of Sarah Jo Pender and Richard Hull — a case that would eventually grab national headlines when Sarah escaped from prison and disappeared.

While the world focused on the spectacle of her escape, the story of Andrew and Tricia quietly faded into the background.

This episode brings the focus back where it belongs — on two lives that were cut short, on the gray areas that make people human, and on the truth that a troubled past should never be a death sentence.

Because this story isn’t just about a fugitive.

It's about Andrew and Tricia who were more than their records. two lives that mattered — and a justice system that struggled to protect their memory.

🎨 Get your tickets now for our live show on Friday January 30th!
Join us at Painting with a Twist in Colorado Springs for a True Crime & DIY Craft Night with a free drink included —

Tickets are going fast, so grab yours before they sell out!

Live Show! True Crime & DIY Craft Night FREE DRINK - Friday, January 30, 2026 - Painting with a Twist Colorado Springs, CO - East

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes can be found at Justiceforpodcast.com 

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In August 1995, 32-year-old Donnah Winger was violently attacked inside her home in Springfield, Illinois. The case was closed quickly by police after speaking with her husband and getting his side of what happened, just to be opened years later after a shocking witness came forward. 

In this episode, we break down the evidence, the lies and betrayal, and the lingering questions that continue to divide opinions decades later. Buckle up for this one buttercups. 

Tickets for out live show on January 30th at painting with a twist are available now!

Get them before they sell out!

Live Show! True Crime & DIY Craft Night FREE DRINK - Friday, January 30, 2026 - Painting with a Twist Colorado Springs, CO - East

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes can be found at Justiceforpodcast.com 

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In this episode, we dive into the haunting story of the Snowden family murders—a case tangled in tragedy, second chances, and whispers of a family curse. Once a well-known Southern family, the Snowdens’ legacy would be shattered by violence not once, but decades apart.

In the 1990s, a mother and her nephew were brutally murdered. The killer was caught, convicted, and eventually released—given another chance at life. But nearly 20 years later, history took a chilling turn when the same man returned…and another member of the Snowden family was killed.

Was this fate, failure of the system, or something darker? We walk through the timelines, the investigations, the parole decision, and the devastating aftermath for a family forced to relive its worst nightmare.

Join us as we ask: How many chances does a killer get—and when does tragedy start to look like a curse?

🎨 Live Show Alert! Join us for our next live show at Painting with a Twist on Friday, January 30th, 2026. True crime, creativity, and a night you won’t want to miss!

Tickets Available Now!

Justiceforpodcast.com

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

For Show notes for this episode head over to Justiceforpodcast.com

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

On April 26, 2006, a devastating crash in Indiana claimed the lives of five Taylor University students. Among those involved were Whitney Cerak and Laura Van Ryn, two young women who had only met earlier that day while helping serve their community.

In the confusion that followed, identities were assigned, families were notified, and a funeral was held—while another family waited beside a hospital bed, unaware of the truth. What unfolded next was not the result of malice, but of chaos, trauma, and assumptions made in the darkest moments.

This episode explores one of the most haunting cases of mistaken identity, the unimaginable impact on two families, and how the truth finally came to light—changing everything.

🎄 Holiday Merch + Live Show Announcement 🎄
Support the show and rep your favorite true crime podcast this holiday season. Grab $15 t-shirts and $20 crewnecks, plus take 15% off your entire order with code JFPXMAS15 (good through December 31).

🎨 Live Show Alert! Join us for our next live show at Painting with a Twist on Friday, January 30th, 2026. True crime, creativity, and a night you won’t want to miss. Tickets and details coming soon.

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes 

https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2016/04/28/cerak-vanryn-mistaken-identity-taylor-university/83639026/ 

https://guideposts.org/positive-living/health-and-wellness/life-advice/managing-life-changes/my-sisters-mistaken-identity/ 

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3564235/Woman-came-dead-car-crash-mistaken-identity-case-recalls-horror-ten-years-anniversary.html 
More at Justiceforpodcast.com

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In March 2023, Angela Craig was rushed to the hospital in Aurora, Colorado, after suddenly falling gravely ill. What doctors first believed was a medical emergency soon unraveled into something far more sinister. Within days, Angela was dead—and the man at her bedside, her husband of more than a decade, was under intense scrutiny.

James Craig, a respected dentist and father of six, was living a double life. As investigators dug deeper, they uncovered disturbing online searches, secret affairs, and allegations of deliberate poisoning carried out over time inside the family home. What initially looked like a tragic loss quickly became a chilling case of betrayal, manipulation, and calculated murder.

In this episode, we break down the timeline leading up to Angela Craig’s death, the red flags missed along the way, and how prosecutors built a case against the person she trusted most. This is the story of a marriage turned deadly—and a reminder that sometimes the greatest danger is the one closest to you.

🎄 Holiday Merch + Live Show Announcement 🎄
Support the show and rep your favorite true crime podcast this holiday season. Grab $15 t-shirts and $20 crewnecks, plus take 15% off your entire order with code JFPXMAS15 (good through December 31).

🎨 Live Show Alert! Join us for our next live show at Painting with a Twist on Friday, January 30th, 2026 True crime, creativity, and a night you won’t want to miss. https://www.paintingwithatwist.com/studio/coloradosprings/calendar/open-studio/

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes 

Angela Dawn Pray Craig Obituary March 18, 2023 - Horan & McConaty Funeral Service and Cremation

23CR664 Affidavit Craig James Toliver Redacted.pdf

For the rest of the show notes head to Justiceforpodcast.com

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In Part 2 of our deep dive into the murder of Betsy Faria, we pick up where the courtroom left Russ behind — branded a killer, sitting in a prison cell, while the truth continued to scream just outside the record.

This chapter is all about what happened after the verdict: the evidence that didn’t make it to the jury, the witnesses who were never heard, and the pieces of the puzzle that refused to stay buried. As new files surface and overlooked details come roaring back into focus, one name starts showing up everywhere.

We trace how Pam Hupp was pulled into the spotlight, how investigators finally started asking the right questions, and how the story of Betsy’s death twisted into something even darker than anyone imagined in that first trial. Insurance policies, timelines, “helpful friends,” bizarre interviews — the truth didn’t come quietly, and neither do we.

Because in this case, justice was not a straight line.

Russ isn’t done fighting.

The system isn’t done denying.

And Pam? …well, Pam is just getting started.

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes 

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/83086318/elizabeth_kay-faria

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7192769/First-police-interview-released-woman-sentenced-life-prison-killing-man.html  https://people.com/crime/russ-faria-framed-for-murdering-his-wife-on-accused-killer-pam-hupp/  

We couldn't fit all the show notes in, please check out our website for the complete list. Justiceforpodcast.com

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In this bonus episode, we open with the most recent twist in the Morgan Geyser Saga — her escape, the brief period she was missing, and the eventual capture that brought her back into custody. We’ll talk about what we know, what’s emerged since, and why the situation has so many people asking hard questions all over again. This is our space to pause, reflect, and unpack the developments before we step back into the story that started it all.

Then, we take you back to where it began: the survival story of Peyton Leutner. After the updates, you’ll hear our original episode in full — a retelling of the 2014 Slender Man stabbing, the unimaginable violence Peyton endured, and how she found the strength to survive the unthinkable.

🎟️ LIVE SHOW ANNOUNCEMENT + HOLIDAY MERCH

We’re hitting the stage January 30th for a live show — and we’d love to see you there. Mark your calendars, grab your tickets, and come experience an episode in person. It’s one night, one room, and the stories we can only tell live.

And while you’re planning ahead, check out our holiday merch drop! Hoodies, tees, cozy true-crime essentials — all available now. Use code JFPXMAS15 at checkout for 15% off your entire order. Treat yourself, your fellow fiends, or slip something under the tree. 🎄🔪

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes 

Bodycam videos show how ‘Slender Man' attacker was found in Posen after escape

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In this episode, we focus on Betsy Faria: a mother, a friend, and a woman fighting through the final chapters of a long cancer battle. We walk through her last day — the chemo appointment, the holiday plans, and the small decisions that seemed ordinary at the time but would become chilling in hindsight.

It was a night that forever changed the people who loved her and set off a chain of events no one could have predicted. This episode centers on Betsy’s life, her strength, and the moments leading up to the tragedy that sparked one of Missouri’s most shocking cases.

Part 1 ends here, at the moment her world — and everyone’s around her — suddenly shifted. Be sure to join us next week for part 2 to find out what really happened and how everyone was involved.

Our brand new Holiday Collection just dropped — and you’re gonna want to wrap this one up with a bow. 🎁

$15 T-Shirts
$20 Crew Necks
PLUS — take 15% off your entire order with code: JFPXMAS15
(Valid through December 31st 🎄)

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes can be found on our website under this episode Justiceforpodcast.com

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

In 1995, 13-year-old Thad Phillips was abducted from his home in Baraboo, Wisconsin and held captive by a teenage predator later known as The Bone Breaker. For nearly two days, Thad endured unimaginable torture—but refused to give up. His daring escape not only saved his own life, but exposed a pattern of violence that could have claimed more victims.

This episode examines Thad’s extraordinary will to survive, the chilling behavior of his attacker, and how one boy’s courage changed the course of a horrifying case.

Disclaimer 

The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.

Show Notes 

(3) Thadius Phillips | Facebook

Fundraiser by Olga Johnson : Support Thad Phillips: Real Hero Of Baraboo

State v. Joseph C. Clark

Kidnapped and tortured by the 'Bonebreaker' Survivor never receives $21M award | News | wkow.com

Joe Clark | Criminal Minds Wiki | Fandom

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557246968627

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/justiceforpodcast

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpodcast?_t=8mHHqktOEEV&_r=1

YouTube https://youtube.com/@justiceforpodcast?si=rI5sP7MltdqZMZuE

This week, we’re re-releasing one of our Season 1 cases from the vault — the heartbreaking story of Mia Campos. Due to some unexpected technical difficulties (because of course they happen on a Monday), we’re giving this episode a fresh spotlight just as Mia’s long-awaited trial is finally set to begin.

In this episode, we revisit the life of a young woman whose disappearance shook her community and sparked questions that still demand answers. We walk back through the timeline, the investigation, the suspects, and the quiet details that were overlooked the first time around.

As the courtroom prepares to open its doors, Mia’s case is more important than ever. This is a chance to remember what’s at stake — justice, truth, and a voice for Mia.

Tune in, refresh your memory, and get ready for what comes next in the fight for accountability.

Follow us @justice for podcast on all platforms for discussion posts and more!

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?...

Instagram  / justiceforpodcast  

igsh=MTQ2ajlzNXI5b2Jjcw%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@justiceforpod...
YouTube   / @justiceforpodcast