Karmelo Anthony’s lethal force against Austin Metcalf during a 2025 teenage track meet scuffle was not justified.  

That was the finding of the Texas jury in Anthony’s case last week. The same panel sentenced the 19-year-old to 35 years in prison for murder.

Yet the conviction remains a topic of intense interest and controversy. It has been framed as a racial injustice by Anthony’s supporters despite testimony from a number of witnesses that he was not in danger. 

Metcalf, 17, another local athlete, died for nothing and the verdict was deserved, others say.

In this episode, James Stainton, a district attorney from another county in the greater Dallas area, breaks down the law and how it applies.   

Stainton explains to The Trial: USA’s Kayla Brantley that the jury followed the law. 

Tune in for this in-depth analysis on Anthony’s case. 

Follow us on TikTok: @DailyMailCrime

Email us: [email protected]

WhatsApp us: +44 7796 657512 Start your message with Trial

Presenter: Kayla Brantley

Producer: Shayna Jacobs and Lucy Robson

Editor: Chelsey Moore

Creative Director: Caroline Cheetham

Executive Producer: Jamie East

Click here to sign up to The Crime Desk's weekly newsletter.

It's free and packed with exclusive interviews, expert insight, and gripping deep dive investigations from across the world.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.