In this episode, Trent confesses to his new addiction of "rage-baiting" Ohio State fans on Twitter before the hosts welcome Jamie Jordan, the "IU Reactionary," to discuss the monumental shift in the program under Cignetti. The group analyzes the "dead asleep" start against Wisconsin, debating whether the offense is sputtering due to boredom or genuine issues with the pass rush, while expressing frustration over the lack of transparency regarding key injuries. They also dive into the future of the roster, discussing Cignetti's sustainable recruiting strategy that avoids overspending on five-star talent, and conclude with Jamie's bold 34-31 prediction for the upcoming clash with Ohio State.

You can read Jamie at Hoosier Huddle and follow him on twitter @jordanjamie.

In this episode, Trent kicks off the show with a hilarious story about getting into a Twitter beef with an active IU player who searched his own name, leading to an onslaught from the "burner universe." The hosts then try to make sense of the 11-0 Hoosiers' sluggish, "dead asleep" start against Wisconsin, raising major questions about whether the offense is "sputtering" and if Mike Shanahan is getting figured out—just like last season. They look ahead to the bye week as a crucial time for "self-scouting" before the Purdue "dress rehearsal" and the massive showdown with Ohio State. The guys also take a victory lap watching the SEC stumble over itself, analyze the Heisman race, and, in a surprise third segment, break down just how excited fans should be about the hot start for Indiana Basketball.

Trent and Tim open the episode by discussing the controversy surrounding Dan Dakich's appearance at the Upstairs Pub, expressing sympathy for the bar's social media manager who is "taking all the arrows". They quickly pivot to the latest College Football Playoff rankings, where Indiana held its #2 spot, effectively guaranteeing a top-four seed even with a future loss to Ohio State. The hosts analyze the media "battle lines," noting the clear bias between the SEC-focused ESPN and the Big Ten-focused Fox/CBS , and they express concern over Ohio State's "flip the switch" mentality, suggesting they haven't truly been tested.

The conversation then turns to the "revenge game" against Wisconsin, referencing both an infamous 83-20 loss in 2010 and Luke Fickell's past win over IU with Cincinnati. They dismiss Wisconsin as "not feisty" and joke that the only way Indiana could lose is via a "catastrophic event". Instead, they frame the game as a chance for the Hoosiers to refine their passing game chemistry and get crucial reps for young defensive backs in preparation for the playoffs. To cap it off, Tim predicts an 84-0 shutout as payback for 2010, while Trent takes the Hoosiers in a 63-0 blowout.

Recapping #2 Indiana's historic 27-24 victory over Penn State, which moves them to 10-0 on the season. They describe the game as a "cold plunge"—a nerve-wracking affair where Indiana failed to pull away despite opportunities, allowing Penn State's talent to keep the game close. They analyze the defense's struggles with missed tackles against Penn State's "blue chip" running backs and the offense's "disjointed" play, which included a critical end-zone drop by Omar Cooper Jr. and a late interception from Fernando Mendoza. The game was saved by Mendoza's "Heisman moment" 87-yard drive with no timeouts, capped by Cooper's "greatest catch of all time" to secure Indiana's first-ever win in Beaver Stadium. The hosts conclude the win proves the team has "clutch genes" and can win under adversity, which will be crucial as they head toward a likely Big Ten Championship game against Ohio State.

In their preview of the Penn State game, Trent and Tim discuss reports that the Nittany Lions are on "quit watch". Despite this, Trent remains nervous about playing a "brand" program in a stadium where Indiana has never won. Answering a listener question, they speculate the team's classic uniform look is a "Cignetti decision" to "keep it simple". They agree Indiana wins by establishing the run but could lose in a "let down game".

In their chaotic first-ever live episode, Trent and Tim react in real-time to the debut of the College Football Playoff rankings. After battling technical difficulties and having to follow along on Twitter because neither of them has ESPN, they dive into the reveal. 

The official rankings place Ohio State at #1, Indiana at #2, Texas A&M at #3, and Alabama at #4. The hosts are ecstatic with Indiana's #2 ranking but are shocked to see Oregon ranked at #9. They quickly identify that Oregon's low placement (and their poor showing against Wisconsin) is the primary reason the committee kept Indiana from the top spot.

Trent kicks off the episode with an "iso-rant" against the "delusional" and "embarrassing" segment of the Indiana and sports fanbase on Twitter, particularly those who claim the new playoff rankings "don't matter". The guys then recap the dominant win over Maryland , which started as a "heart attack"-inducing game. An early string of injuries to Elijah Surratt (hamstring), Aiden Fisher, and offensive lineman Drew Evans caused panic, and replacement Zen Michalski looked "absolutely lost" on several plays. Despite the scare, the defense settled in to hold Maryland to just 10 points , while the rushing attack, led by Black and Hemby, took over the game.

The "Heisman-Doza" campaign took a slight hit as Fernando Mendoza had a quiet 201 passing yards. Tim gleefully recounts how Cignetti called a specific "stat-padding" play for Mendoza to cross a 200-yard betting line before immediately pulling him from the game. With Mendoza sitting out so many fourth quarters, Trent concedes Ohio State's Julian Sayin is now the Heisman favorite.

Finally, the guys analyze the crucial upcoming Oregon vs. Iowa game, debating which outcome is better for Indiana's resume. The episode concludes with Trent cackling at the "fraud" Mario Cristobal for Miami's loss to SMU and Tim comparing the chaotic Auburn football program to the "Colombian government getting overthrown every six weeks".

Trent and Tim are so unconcerned about the upcoming road game against Maryland that they dedicate the majority of their preview episode to a special interview with internet personality and IU superfan, Hoosier Commish. The Commish comes out firing, ranting about how Ty Simpson is being "mysteriously" snuck into the Heisman #1 spot over Fernando Mendoza. He also details his ongoing, real-life FOIA quest to unearth Cignetti's introductory press conference from James Madison University, which has "mysteriously gone without a trace from the entirety of the internet".

The interview covers Commish's "terrorist organization" ranking for the Illinois fanbase , his experience getting threatened with ejection for yelling at UCLA coach Jerry Neuheisel , and his nostalgia for former coach Bill Lynch. His biggest surprise player of the season is linebacker Isaiah Jones , and he boldly predicts Indiana is building an "Alabama type of dynasty" and will win "two to three national titles" under Cignetti.

After the interview, the guys briefly turn their attention to Maryland. They discuss Cignetti's hilarious press conference where he hyped up the Terps like they were the "'85 Bears," a classic psychological move they compare to Bobby Bowden. They conclude the only way Indiana loses is a "pure fantasy" scenario where Maryland's freshman QB Malik Washington plays a perfect game. Finally, they give their players of the game and their blowout predictions.

Trent and Tim revel in Indiana's continued dominance after a 56-6 dismantling of UCLA, the Hoosiers' second 50-point win against a Power Four opponent this season. They discuss the symbolism of the IU victory flag getting stuck atop the Memorial Stadium flagpole, refusing to come down just like the team refuses to lose. With top-5 rankings in both offense and defense, the guys debate if Indiana has become the juggernaut team that seemed absent from college football this year.

Fernando "Heisman-Doza" Mendoza remains the Heisman favorite despite a statistically quieter game , while the defense stepped up, highlighted by an early pick-six from Aiden Fisher and strong play from Stephen Daly filling in for the injured Kellen Wyatt. Looking ahead, they dismiss Maryland as a serious threat and preview crucial upcoming Big Ten games involving Iowa, Oregon, Ohio State, and Penn State, analyzing how the results could impact Indiana's playoff path and strength of schedule. They finish by discussing the wild coaching carousel possibilities and how Cignetti's recent extension might only be the first one he signs this season due to rising market prices.

The episode kicks off with a heated debate between Trent and Tim over running back "roster management," as Trent argues Khobie Martin needs reps while Tim insists on keeping him in "AAA" to stay healthy for next year. The guys then turn their attention to the upcoming matchup against UCLA, referring to their interim coach Jerry Neuheisel as a "grown-up Hey Arnold" and dismissing their recent win streak as a product of weak competition. They break down the significant season-ending injury to defensive end Kellan Wyatt and discuss how the defense will adapt without him.

Both hosts agree that the path to victory involves Fernando "Heisman-Doza" Mendoza having a surgical day against a "so bad" UCLA defense, while the IU defense confuses QB Nico Iamaleava with spies and complex schemes. While Tim predicts a 42-14 win, Trent calls for a 56-0 shutout, declaring it the "Tino Sunseri Revenge Game" for Indiana's former co-offensive coordinator.