Penny thought her dinner date with Abraham was a hit — great vibes, shared laughs, and even dessert. She encouraged him to send back his disappointing dish, thinking that was the only hiccup of the night. But midway through dinner, Penny dropped a piece of personal news that left Abraham baffled and unsure about her intentions. And that’s the real reason he’s been silent ever since.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Charlie and Zoey's first date went really well and even ended up back at his place to watch a movie. However, Charlie hasn't heard back since their movie night and thinks maybe he was a little too forward with Zoey. Zoey gives us the rundown of a rude "guest" that showed up during the movie that scared off Zoey entirely. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Adam and Leslie hit it off after meeting at a gala and decided to meet again for dinner just a few days later. But when Leslie showed up to the restaurant, she says something felt totally different, like the guy she met had vanished. Now Adam’s confused about why he hasn’t heard from her… but Leslie says it all comes down to how he looked that night.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Skylar and Nico met up for a fun dinner date, but the night took a wild turn when Nico’s car disappeared from the valet. What started as a promising evening ended with confusion, a police report, and Skylar wondering if she’d just been part of a very strange situation. But was it all as it seemed? Find out on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Dennis and Scarlet hit it off on Hinge and even went on a couple of dinner dates, but now Dennis can’t get a single response. He thought everything went smoothly… until the texts started. According to Scarlet, what he sent after the dates was so bizarre, she couldn’t unsee it and definitely couldn’t stick around.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Asher thought his casual burger date with Gretchen went off without a hitch: good conversation, great vibes, and nothing he’d consider a dealbreaker. But Gretchen says as soon as the food hit the table, everything changed. It wasn’t what he said... it was how he ate that had her quietly planning her exit.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Trey admits their first date didn’t start off perfectly: he was a few minutes late, forgot a reservation, and kept pulling into handicap parking spots all night. Kayla stayed polite but says something about the placard didn’t sit right, and she started suspecting the worst. But in Part 2, the truth comes out, and it’s something Kayla definitely didn’t see coming.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ty, recently divorced and reentering the dating world, set up a charming backyard picnic for his first date with Cassidy. Everything seemed to be going well until she suddenly made an early exit and ghosted him completely. Cassidy says the date itself wasn’t the problem… but what she found in his bathroom had her running for the door.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark says his first date with Lily was practically flawless: great chemistry, meaningful conversation, and even a kiss goodnight. But since then, Lily has completely disappeared, and Mark has no idea why. When we talked to Lily, she said the date was amazing…until she found out something about Mark that made things very awkward.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

After chatting online, Allie let Joey plan their first date, and told him she wanted to be surprised. Joey took that to heart and went all-in with a bold, adrenaline-pumping activity. Now she’s not calling him back, and Joey’s wondering if his “high-flying” idea might’ve been a little too intense.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.