Mooney and Tiffany go way back to their high school days and Mooney still sees himself as the same ladies’ man he used to be. So why is Tiffany leaving him on read after their date? Let’s just say, Tiffany thinks he peaked in high school and things spiral fast when Mooney hears that. It gets messy on this episode of Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Murphy took Jessica to a comedy club on their first date and is worried her being the punchline to a joke may have rubbed her the wrong way. Jessica joins the show fill you in on the entire experience

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Sammie admits her date with Thomas didn’t exactly light the world on fire, but she was still curious why he ghosted her completely. When we got Thomas on the line, he said it wasn’t anything Sammie did, just something he noticed… and couldn't unsee. What did Thomas mean by “a little lopsided”, and was it really worth disappearing over?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Amelia was pretty smitten over Logan after their first date. He was tall, handsome, smelled good, and even had some nice physical touch moments on their date but heard absolutely nothing from him after the date concluded. Logan joins the show to explain how he doesn't think he can meet her needs.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Nicholas thought things were going well after being set up with Rhonda through mutual friends. He was open about being in between jobs but optimistic about his prospects. However, after one date, Rhonda completely vanished, and when we got her on the phone, it became clear she had some serious concerns about his independence. Find out on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Luke says his date with Erika was one of those rare, instant-chemistry moments, nonstop conversation, shared laughs, and a mutual feeling that this might actually go somewhere. But after what seemed like the perfect night, Erika suddenly vanished. From Luke’s perspective, everything went right, including a moment where he handed her his phone to show off photos of his recent kitchen remodel. But Erika remembers something else popping up on that screen… something that made her question everything. Find out on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wyatt thought he was finally meeting his perfect match when he took Lila out for dinner after hitting it off over messages. But when the night arrived, their conversation fell flat and the connection felt completely different. It wasn’t until he got back to his car and checked his phone that the real twist dropped, Lila had texted saying she wouldn’t be able to make the date… so who was sitting across from him all night?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Joseph thought taking Raegan to a baseball game would be the perfect first date, after all, baseball is his life. He coaches, he watches, and he talks about it nonstop. But Raegan left the date with a dugout full of doubts, especially after meeting a few of his players… and catching a strange vibe. What started as a fun outing ended in her questioning way more than just his strike zone. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

David and Margo hit it off after meeting at a company mixer. Their dinner date ended with David offering her a ride home, a move that felt thoughtful and genuine on his part. But after that night… nothing. Margo’s been silent. When we finally got her on the phone, it became clear she remembered that night very differently, especially the moment they pulled into her apartment complex. Find out what happened on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Chris thought he had the perfect evening, dinner, drinks, great chemistry, and even a run-in with his coworkers and boss that felt like a fun coincidence. But after that night, Kat disappeared. When we finally got her on the phone, we discovered she may have had a very different agenda all along. Let’s just say… Chris was not the only familiar face at that bar. Find out why Chris called Kat a "terrible person" on this episode of Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.