Joseph thought taking Raegan to a baseball game would be the perfect first date, after all, baseball is his life. He coaches, he watches, and he talks about it nonstop. But Raegan left the date with a dugout full of doubts, especially after meeting a few of his players… and catching a strange vibe. What started as a fun outing ended in her questioning way more than just his strike zone. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

David and Margo hit it off after meeting at a company mixer. Their dinner date ended with David offering her a ride home, a move that felt thoughtful and genuine on his part. But after that night… nothing. Margo’s been silent. When we finally got her on the phone, it became clear she remembered that night very differently, especially the moment they pulled into her apartment complex. Find out what happened on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Chris thought he had the perfect evening, dinner, drinks, great chemistry, and even a run-in with his coworkers and boss that felt like a fun coincidence. But after that night, Kat disappeared. When we finally got her on the phone, we discovered she may have had a very different agenda all along. Let’s just say… Chris was not the only familiar face at that bar. Find out why Chris called Kat a "terrible person" on this episode of Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Tara and Jason met through mutual friends and hit it off on their first date, dinner, drinks, and lots of fun chemistry. So when Tara invited him over for a chill second hang at her place (with a few friends possibly stopping by), Jason expected a casual night. Instead, he walked into something very unexpected that left him speechless. Find out on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ethan and Priscilla’s low-key BBQ date ended up taking a wild turn once they hit the road. Priscilla thought things were going smoothly until Ethan got pulled over and responded in a way that left her speechless. What should have been a simple traffic stop turned into an unexpected sovereignty stand-off....and Priscilla wasn’t sticking around for that. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ryan thought their first date was a chaotic, hilarious, all-around win. The kind of night that ends in nonstop laughs and texts that keep the spark going. But Sophie suddenly ghosted him, and Ryan’s only theory is a minor stumble he made walking back to his truck. When Sophie finally tells her side, though, it turns out what she saw the next day completely changed everything. Find out on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Nick and Meghan had known each other through mutual friends, and their first official date, a simple night out at the movies, seemed like a solid step forward. But what happened after the credits rolled has Meghan saying she’s lucky to have made it out in one piece. So what did Nick do in the parking lot that completely killed the vibe?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Paul thought he and Jana had real chemistry, a rooftop date filled with laughs, flirting, and even a kiss goodnight. But after that magical evening, Jana completely vanished. When we got her on the phone, she revealed that she saw something very suspicious while Paul was showing her pictures of his dog. Did she catch Paul living a double life? Find out on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Hillary thought her flirty office friendship with Shane had finally turned into something special after a great first date, until he started dodging her at work and completely iced her out. She was shocked to hear that HR had pulled him into a meeting, especially since she never meant to report anything. But when Shane reveals what was actually in the routine “relationship disclosure” she filed, everything changes,  because HR didn’t just see a new romance… they saw a personnel problem.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Marissa thought she was on the path to a second date after spending a great evening with Caleb, dinner, drinks, and even meeting his adorable new puppy. But when a neighbor dropped off a misdelivered package, Marissa made what she thought was a harmless joke: “Don’t worry, I’m not the wife. I’m the fun one!” That single line detonated a chain reaction that turned Caleb’s entire apartment complex against him. Find out all the neighborhood drama on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.