Ignoring your haters is not the answer.
Here’s why:
In March of 2025 my daughter and I winged our way thousands of miles across the country to catch a few Yankee spring training games in Tampa, Florida.
The vibe at these spring games was absolutely delicious.
The crowds were so much smaller than regular season games in the big stadiums and it was just the most relaxing setting to spend a couple hours chatting and watching your favorite players get ready for Opening Day.
I’d go as far as to call it serene.
Except for the moment when that one Tigers fan decided to express VERY LOUDLY how overrated he felt Yankee right fielder Aaron Judge was during a first inning at bat.
That part was less than serene.
So much less than serene that the fan was removed from the stadium. In the bottom of the first inning. During a spring training game.
The fan was brash, fully out of line, and would be proven definitively wrong when Aaron Judge went on to hit .331 (the best in his league) with 53 home runs, earning the American League MVP by the end of the 2025 season.
And I really hope big Aaron Judge heard what he had to say.
Plot twist.
You’ve probably been told to ignore the haters, but I want to argue for a more measured approach.
Leadership requires you to make unpopular decisions and take responsibility for things that don’t go to plan. All of which set you up for criticism. Some of which will be patently unfair.
But if the goal is to be the best leader you can be, you can’t choose to dismiss the opinions of your detractors out of hand just because they don’t like you.
You don’t have to believe everything people say about you, but you should be able to open your curiosity filter to say, “what does this mean?”
In my 5 Secrets of Impossibly Effective Teams workshops I highlight the value of leveraging trust and a consistent posture of wanting to help your people win as the best way to have your encouragement and correction taken seriously, but don’t assume that the only valuable encouragement and correction comes from people who care about you.
If you play your cards right you might find that your haters accidentally give you a really valuable insight from time to time.
Don’t waste it.
TRY THIS: The next time you want to dismiss uncomfortable feedback because the messenger isn’t someone you trust, follow this framework:
Can I easily disprove this? This is not about rationalizing it away because you know your intentions, but about asking yourself – like a lawyer – if there is legitimate evidence that this is inaccurate? If so, you’re done. Considered and rejected. Move on.
Have I heard something like this before? Does this match other feedback you’ve received in the past? Is there a chance you’re feeling defensive because they might be onto something? If there is a chance this fits a subtle pattern, consider other places this has shown up to determine if there is a real opportunity to close a performance gap.
Phone a friend. If you can’t disprove it, and aren’t sure if a pattern exists, check in with a trusted friend, peer, leader, or coach who will be fully honest with you. “I recently received this feedback from someone I’m not sure I can trust and I’m not sure what to do with it. Can you help me parse it?”
My free PDF, “The 5 Secrets of Impossibly Effective Teams,” will show you the simple leadership moves that help teams unlock their full potential and deliver outsized results, without burning out. Grab your copy now at geoffwelch.com/secrets