Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share [Linkpost] “Histograms are to CDFs as calibration plots are to...” by Optimization Process
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
[Linkpost] “Histograms are to CDFs as calibration plots are to...” by Optimization Process
This is a link post.
As you know, histograms are decent visualizations for PDFs with lots of samples...
10k predictions, 20 bins
...but if there are only a few samples, the histogram-binning choices can matter a lot:
10 predictions, 4 binssame 10 predictions, 7 binsThe binning (a) discards information, and worse, (b) is mathematically un-aesthetic.
But a CDF doesn't have this problem!
same 10 predictions, every data point precisely representedIf you make a bunch of predictions, and you want to know how well they're calibrated, classically you make a graph like this:
source: SSC's 2019 prediction gradingBut, as with a histogram, this depends on how you bin your predictions.
100 predictions, 10 binssame 100 predictions, 30 binsIs there some CDF-like equivalent here? Some visualization with no free parameters?
I asked that question to several people at Arbor Summer Camp. I got three answers:
- "You get from a PDF to [...]
---
First published:
June 5th, 2025
Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/LFGgwitjertJqch7J/histograms-are-to-cdfs-as-calibration-plots-are-to
Linkpost URL:
https://optimizationprocess.com/calibration-cdf/
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---
Images from the article:
Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.
View all episodes
By LessWrongThis is a link post.
As you know, histograms are decent visualizations for PDFs with lots of samples...
10k predictions, 20 bins
...but if there are only a few samples, the histogram-binning choices can matter a lot:
10 predictions, 4 binssame 10 predictions, 7 binsThe binning (a) discards information, and worse, (b) is mathematically un-aesthetic.
But a CDF doesn't have this problem!
same 10 predictions, every data point precisely representedIf you make a bunch of predictions, and you want to know how well they're calibrated, classically you make a graph like this:
source: SSC's 2019 prediction gradingBut, as with a histogram, this depends on how you bin your predictions.
100 predictions, 10 binssame 100 predictions, 30 binsIs there some CDF-like equivalent here? Some visualization with no free parameters?
I asked that question to several people at Arbor Summer Camp. I got three answers:
- "You get from a PDF to [...]
---
First published:
June 5th, 2025
Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/LFGgwitjertJqch7J/histograms-are-to-cdfs-as-calibration-plots-are-to
Linkpost URL:
https://optimizationprocess.com/calibration-cdf/
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---
Images from the article:
Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.
More shows like LessWrong (30+ Karma)
View all
The Daily
112,586 Listeners
Astral Codex Ten Podcast
130 Listeners
Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
7,219 Listeners
Dwarkesh Podcast
531 Listeners
The Ezra Klein Show
16,096 Listeners
AI Article Readings
4 Listeners
Doom Debates
14 Listeners
LessWrong posts by zvi
2 Listeners