This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss an active case that has more questions than answers currently. In one of Toronto’s most affluent neighborhoods, a high-profile couple suddenly dropped off the radar—and the city has been trying to make sense of it ever since. Barry and Honey Sherman were known for their influence, their philanthropy, and the kind of success that made them fixtures of Canadian life. But behind that polished image, something far more unsettling was taking shape. The Shermans moved through circles of power, philanthropy, and industry—admired by some, quietly resented by others. Their world was one of sharp contrasts: generosity paired with controversy, success shadowed by legal battles, and a business empire that made them both respected and disputed figures. So, when tragedy struck, the question hung heavier than the headlines: who—or what—was behind it?

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a case filled with shocking lies and manipulation. In the quiet college town of Eau Claire, Wisconsin, a complicated friendship between two young adults spiraled into something far darker than anyone around them could have imagined. At the center of it all was Alex Woodworth — a thoughtful, introverted barista with a philosophical mind and a gentle presence. What began as an intense emotional entanglement would unravel into a story of blurred boundaries, shifting truths, and a final encounter that raised more questions than answers. This is the case of Alex Woodworth — and the truth behind what happened on that cold March afternoon is anything but simple.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy explore the mysterious case of Kelsey Berreth — a 29-year-old mom who seemed to have everything going for her. She was planning Thanksgiving dinner, texting her fiancé, and running a few last-minute errands... until she suddenly vanished. No signs of struggle. No clear trail. Just a series of puzzling clues that left everyone wondering — what really happened to Kelsey Berreth that Thanksgiving Day?

This week on LOTW, Bevy discusses one of the UK's most notorious serial killers. Joanna Dennehy grew up in the quiet towns of Peterborough and Cambridgeshire, a bright and seemingly ordinary girl. For years, she blended in, charming those around her and moving through life without raising alarm. But as she entered adulthood, drugs and alcohol began to loosen her inhibitions—and with them, a darker, more dangerous side started to surface, one that would leave a wake of terror in her path and set her on a course no one could have predicted.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the final part of the Lucy Letby case.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the gruesome murders of multiple infants. In the quiet halls of a neonatal ward in northwest England, parents placed their newborns in the hands of someone they believed was there to protect them — a kind-faced nurse who seemed to genuinely care. The hospital lights glowed softly through long night shifts, the steady beeping of monitors marking tiny heartbeats and fragile breaths. But beneath the calm surface of the ward, something unthinkable was happening. Before long, tragedy began to strike again and again — and no one could explain why.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a case of disturbed individuals seemingly influenced by metal music in the early 90's. In 1995, It was just another summer evening in Arroyo Grande, California. At 15, Elyse Pahler seemed like a typical high school freshman—quiet, creative, with dreams she hadn’t yet voiced. She lived in a small town, where coming of age usually meant late nights with friends, planning for what came next. One night in July, Elyse received a phone call. She slipped out of her home into the dark, heading toward a place she thought was safe—a place meant for something ordinary. But when daylight came, Elyse couldn't be found. What exactly happened in those hours when Elyse walked away?

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss an unsolved case from 2008.It was a calm summer night in Kearney, Nebraska. Most people were winding down or already asleep. At the edge of town sat a small trailer where 21-year-old Kelcey Fike lived with her boyfriend. She’d recently started working night shifts, was getting used to a new routine, and talked often about her plans for the future. But in the early morning hours, smoke began to rise from the trailer park. Neighbors noticed the glow and called for help. Fire crews arrived within minutes to find Kelcey’s trailer on fire. At first, it seemed like a tragic accident — but as investigators looked closer, they realized something about this fire didn’t make sense.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a tale of betrayal involving a person who was noted by many to have been a very kind, inclusive and witty person. That person was Aaron Davis. Aaron Davis was 21 years old—a recent college graduate with a political science degree, full of ambition and plans for the future. He was making his way across the South, stopping briefly in Georgia before heading to see his girlfriend in Alabama. That night seemed simple enough: a few drinks, some karaoke, and a guest room to crash in until morning. But Aaron never made it to his next destination. When his vehicle turned up abandoned in a local park, a frantic search began.

This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss a case motivated by greed. Keith and Darlene Gentry seemed to have it all—a happy family, a new home, and three young boys. But behind closed doors, financial stress and marital tension were mounting. Then one November morning, Darlene called 911 with a chilling report: her husband was gravely injured, their back door stood open, and his guns were missing. What really happened inside the Gentry home that day? And why did investigators begin to suspect that this wasn’t the work of an intruder at all?