New Jersey mom Michelle Nyce spent the last night of her life working the makeup counter at Macy’s, followed by a romantic tryst with her lover.  When she finally arrived home, her husband was waiting for her in a jealous rage.

Michelle had come all the way from the Philippines when she was just 20-years old to be the wife of 41-year old Dr. Jonathan Nyce.  After 15 years of marriage, they were raising three children together in their luxurious $1.6 million home.  But Jonathan, the former chief executive of a pharmaceutical company, was failing in his career and in his marriage. He was about to lose everything, including Michelle.

Join us at the quiet end for Mail-Order Murder: The Story of Michelle & Jonathan Nyce.  Michelle and Jonathan were an unlikely couple, but they seemed to make things work for a time.  By 2004, their relationship was strained and Michelle had fallen in love with their former gardener.  Was Jonathan capable of killing his pretty, young wife, or was her lover responsible for her death?

Join Tiegrabber for bonus and ad-free shows

Read “Never Leave Me” by Jon Glatt