
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This episode's food selection is from Parkette Family Restaurant, located at 2022 E Pike St, Clarksburg, WV. Open Tue-Sat 11 AM-9 PM, Sun 11 AM-3:30 PM.
Here's what we ordered:
In this episode, Matt covers two brothers who are considered some of the earliest known serial killers in US history, discussing their exploits in the early frontier regions of Appalachia. The main creeps also talk about a preference for mayo and which foods should be dry. The crimes discussed in this episode are graphic, discretion advised.
No food today, the Creeps didn't feel like snacking.
If you have any information that might help in solving the case covered on the show, you can contact the Lawrence County Sherriff's Office Anonymous Tipline at 740-532-3525 or email at [email protected].
If you would like more information about the DNA Doe Project, visit DNADoeProject.org.
DNA Doe Project
In this episode, the Main Creeps try out the food inside a US military MRE food ration. They try barbecue protein puffs, applesauce, coffee, lemonade, barbecue beef, crackers with jelly. Tune in to see if trying this makes them happy or angry. There's a lot of chewing, and they talk about what kind of trades they would make for the good stuff.
Matt covers another cult, this one is known as The House of Prayer church. They been allegedly accused of stealing money from veterans education organizations. Hey, don't scam people.
In this short Horror D'Oeuvres, the Main Creeps try a Spicy Nacho Doritos flavored cheese dip. After they discuss the flavor profiles of various dips, Matt covers the recent stabbing murder of 20 year old Abagail Marcinkowski that took place in January of this year, in Charleston, WV. At the time of recording, a suspect has been arrested, with no further updates.
In this episode we try a local spice blend mulled into a festive warm apple cider. The spices come to us from Sunny Hollow Farms, located in Auburn, WV. Kelsey chose their "naughty toddy" mix packet when she visited their booth at the Bridgeport Farmers Market during the 2022 season. We can't promise that the cider tastes better in our Creep mugs, but it might. It's definitely possible, so go get one...
Kelsey provides a part two covering the killings in Stockton, California, including the arrest and arraignment of their main suspect. The Main Creeps also talk about the 80s and poutine, in which Matt's love of Canada is called into question yet again.
In this episode, we try really hard to open the crinkly packaging wrapped around Hostess flavored iced coffee drinks. We're having the Twinkie and honey bun flavors. We eventually try them once they're finally opened. As promised, Matt gives you an update on what is currently happening with the ongoing investigation of the recent murders in Idaho.
This episode's food selection is from DeNuzzo's Deli
Here's what we ordered:
The Creeps talk about being won over if you hand them free salty meats, and that they're not huge fans of pasta salads but they will tear up any other salad. They also talk about poisoning pickles. Kelsey tells the story of a love triangle, a tent on fire, and several shooting murders that occurred in Northern California in the summer of 2022.
In this episode, we've got homemade Christmas Tree style cakes that were homemade by Kelsey. We tried them side-by-side against the kind made by Little Deb. Matt talks about investigating holiday cookies as a kid. Kelsey covers the story of the Manacled Mormon, in which Kirk Anderson was allegedly abducted and assaulted in the 70s, having been stalked and followed by a former beauty queen. This episode was requested by our editor, Britt.
As Matt says, this one's not gory, we just learn all the places you can hide notes...
In this episode, we get spicy and full of holiday warmth. Main Creep Kelsey creates beautiful Gingerdead men. You've got to try her recipe! Matt talks about the bite of the ginger. Enjoy this cookie with a cup of cheer or another cookie... Matt covers three festive stories about a certain child abduction, zombie Santa, and the brutal stabbing of a famous Christmas icon. Kelsey relays the story of an awful lunch.
Gingerbread
3 c flour
3/4 c butter, softened
1/2 c molasses
Cream together butter and sugar until soft and fluffy. Add molasses and mix well. Add egg, mix well.
Sift your dry ingredients together separately, then slowly add to your wet mixture. Mix until fully combined.
Split dough into 2 equal portions. Wrap each portion in saran wrap and refrigerate at least 2 hrs.
Unwrap and place dough on a floured surface. Sprinkle top of dough in flour as well, then gently roll out to about 1/4 inch thickness. Cut into whatever shapes you like.
Bake at 350°F for 12-15 minutes until edges are done and center is close. Cookies will continue to bake on the hot sheet for up to 15 minutes once out of the oven. Let cool and decorate however you like! Enjoy.
In this episode, we get seasonal and appetizery like our Horror d'Oeuvres namesake! We try jalapeño hot pepper jelly from a local Philippi artisan, it comes to us from Cellar House Harvest. Kelsey dives into the story of Jacob Yerkes, the Tennessee man recently arrested on charges of aggravated stalking and harassment.
We'd like to remind you all to stay the good kind of creepy...
From the publisher's feed