Attorney Franz Borghardt joins the show to discuss the legal complexities surrounding Gad Black’s case, where Black is accused of attempting to murder Baton Rouge Police Sergeant Caleb Alsworth by hitting him with a truck. Black, who allegedly harbors deep animosity toward law enforcement, faces charges of attempted first-degree murder, hate crimes, and resisting an officer. His erratic courtroom behavior and claims of being part of a “tribal nation” raised questions about his mental health, though Borghardt emphasized that mental illness is not a legal excuse unless it impairs the ability to distinguish right from wrong.
Black reportedly bragged about the incident on social media, which could serve as an admission of guilt. His history of violence against police and the targeted nature of the attack support the hate crime charge, which carries an additional five-year sentence. Borghardt stressed the importance of law enforcement handling the case strictly by the book to avoid any procedural missteps that could jeopardize prosecution.
Asia Raby, Black’s girlfriend, was also arrested and charged with obstruction of justice and accessory after the fact to attempted first-degree murder. Her involvement included allegedly moving the truck used in the crime and withholding information. While some criticized her arrest and bond amount, Borghardt noted that her actions, though serious, differ significantly from Black’s and may reflect fear or poor judgment rather than criminal intent. He also addressed misinformation spread online, particularly a video falsely claiming Raby was charged with attempted murder.Borghardt highlighted the legal distinctions between the two defendants, the role of mental health in criminal defense, and the importance of accurate public information in high-profile cases.