Murder In The Hudson Valley

Serial killer Richard Francis Cottingham is serving life in prison, but may have dozens of additional unidentified victims.

Twenty three year old teacher Carole Segretta was shot point blank and left for dead on the side of the road in Yorktown Heights, NY, in 1960. The killer wasn't discovered for 15 years.

Pedro Lopez Monsalve may be one of the most prolific serial killers in history, and nobody knows where he is.

Mary Nagle was brutally murdered in her New City, NY, home in 2005. What sick, twisted things did this killer do to the family and friends of his victim afterward?

How did serial killer Rodney Alcala get on the popular TV show The Dating Game, and win!?

How did lottery winner Joseph Rukaj end up in Sing Sing prison? Was he the target of a blood feud, or did he commit intentional murder?

Who killed Peggy Nadell? Was it a complete stranger, or did someone very close have a few million dollars worth of motive? Linda and Mike share the details of this grizzly murder that occurred in January 2014 in Valley Cottage, NY.

16 year old Carlton Mason brutally murdered two young girls in the woods of Spring Valley, NY, in 1953.

Robert Reldan was a smooth talking murderer who left a path of crime from New Jersey to Rockland County, NY. He was sentenced to life in prison in 1979, but may be eligible for parole in the near future.

Convicted murderer Edgar Smith was such a smooth talker, he even fooled famed attorney William F. Buckley. His known crime streak started with the 1957 murder of 15 year old Victoria Zielinski in Ramsey, New Jersey.