Natalie Bollinger and her twin sister Alycia had a difficult childhood. During a particularly rough part of their early teenage years, Natalie struck up a friendship with a much older homeless man named Shawn Schwartz. When they had a falling out & Natalie cut off all ties, Shawn didn't take it well. She posted a very public Facebook status about him and 2 weeks later she went missing. The truth behind what happened is shocking, as is what happened to her sister only 3 years later.

Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh

Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTube