What might a 720-year-old epic poem offer the working professional, parent, teacher, healthcare worker, or leader of the 21st Century? Plenty. I recently completed a course on Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy, a journey through Inferno, Purgatory, and into Paradise through the lens of this 14th Century poet. The work, comprised of three books with the names above, is a tour de force of poetic form, historical commentary, philosophical exploration, psychological insight, and theological reflection. For the me, the books have provided a profoundly revelatory burst of intellectual curiosity and I will be contemplating Dante’s wisdom and insight for years to come. There is far too much to unpack in a few posts but I wanted to offer a bit deeper dive into these works through a modern reflection on each book offered over the next three weeks. Whether or not you’ve journeyed into the Divine Comedy, I hope this piques your curiosity and inspires deeper reflection on some of the insights I’ve gleaned from his brilliant work.
What’s the Point? A Journey Into Dante’s Inferno
Looking at me sincerely, she replied, “Jesus wants your heart.” After reading 34 Cantos, watching 34 videos and a documentary, reading thousands of words of supplementary material, and participating in four robust class discussions on Dante and The Inferno, I found myself spinning in the facts, characters, imagery, opinion, history, and legend, of this classic work and its author. The layers and intricacies astounded and confounded me. I found myself stuck, frozen in the Cocytus under the flapping wings of Lucifer in my own lead-lined cloak of gold, hypocritically grasping for complete understanding even as I critiqued Ulysses’ sin, suspecting it more than slightly reflective of Dante’s own disordered quest for knowledge.
Sensing profundity hidden behind the veiled references and clever rhyme, I grasped, frustrated, asking, “What’s the point?” Sally’s pronouncement landed like a thunderous punch from the giant, Antaeus, shaking the 9th Circle of Hell. The voices of numerous scholarly commentators came to my mind, counseling a reading of The Divine Comedy knowing it is also reading me. The Inferno is the first leg of Dante’s spiritual journey which will ultimately lead him to Paradise and the fulfillment of all desires in the Beatific Vision. “Jesus wants your heart,” she repeated. The Inferno suddenly had purpose beyond the facts and figures, for me and for those who move in the world with me. The words of my patient wife chased chaos away like a terza rima wave artistically ordering the thoughts of the Poet.
Waking the following morning, a Pope Benedict XVI reflection transported me on this Feast Day of Saint Benedict of Nursia, into the vision that led the Saint up the mountain to a tower and into the upper room – symbolic of Jesus’ Last Supper with the Apostles. Here, Saint Benedict looked out the single window to see the wall of the world removed while earth and heaven were revealed. Dante’s vision in the Divine Comedy reflects heaven and earth, as well as the distance between. The Inferno is a revelation of what sits in between: sin and its distancing effect from the Bread of Life. Saint Benedict’s efforts to preserve Roman texts through the ending of the Roman Empire, gave the pilgrim Dante access to Virgil, Dante the poet’s heavenly choice to guide him through the Inferno, eight hundred years later. Saint Benedict also gave the world The Rule, a book on structure and order which, not only underpinned Benedictine monastic life, but served as the blueprint for European civilization post Roman Empire, and points to the structure and order of the Inferno. Both echo the ordered symmetry of Creation, the fashion in which God brings cosmos from chaos.
Dante builds his epic on mathematical structure and order, using terza rima, a rhyming structure built on three-line stanzas, to symbolize the Trinity. Is it random chance that Saint Benedict’s Feast Day falls on our last day of discussion of the Inferno? For Dante, Fortune is a general minister of God, “scrambling now and then the empty goods from race to race, from one blood to another, past all defense man’s shrewdness might devise” (Canto VII, 78-80). In Dante’s universe, even chance answers to God’s great plan. From across the centuries, Saint Benedict pronounces his first rule, “Ausculto” or listen, challenging us to hear God’s voice and see the Divine threads crossing time from his vision to Dante’s Inferno, and what it can tell us today.
We’ve Lost Our Sense of Sin
Dante starts the Inferno, “Midway upon the journey of our life.” A place where he realizes: “I found myself in a dark wilderness, for I had wandered from the straight and true.” Nearly a thousand years later, sixties singer Norman Greenbaum reflects the spirit of modernity in Spirit in the Sky, “Never been a sinner, I never sinned. I got a friend in Jesus.” Looking around, Dante sees a path to Heaven, but realizes his way is blocked by a leopard (excessive appetite), a lion (representing bestial violence), and then a ravenous she-wolf (representing avarice, fraud, and treachery). Sin has beset him, barring his way to paradise, and only the appearance of Virgil, sent by Beatrice in Paradiso, saves the pilgrim Dante from these beasts.
Modern culture has relegated sin to the guilt-ridden dogma of backward religion. “I’ve never been a sinner” might be a cultural slogan telling us there should be no guilt, and even those believing in Jesus often see him as the friendly hippy, loving everyone without judgment – just or otherwise. American culture in particular festers in a pool of subjective truth, affirming that “I’m alright and you’re alright,” in whatever ways we choose to live our lives. Our hyper-focus on individual rights and self-determination has obscured objective truth, and the very real dangers to our humanity, and our soul, when we guide our lives by our everchanging desires. “In those days there was no king in Israel, but every man did that which was right in his own eyes” (Judges 17:6).
For the modern Catholic on his or her own journey, as well as the budding evangelist, one of Dante’s lasting gifts is to give us a dimensional perspective on the nature of sin as a barrier to eternal joy as well as earthly happiness. The image of hell in the Inferno gives us both geography and topography, evoking a sense of distance and depth. Approaching the city of Dis, Dante observes, “We sped along into the deep-trenched moats that fortify that never-solaced land, the city seemed to loom with iron walls” (Canto 8, Lines 76-78). Here, hell consumes space with ominous, imposing presence. “At the edge of a ring of broken stones, heaped in a tumble down to the steep pit, we came upon a crueler pack of woe, where for the horrid overwhelming stink belched up out of the depths of the abyss…” (Canto 11, Lines 1-5). Dante takes us on a sensual journey into the depths of sin as he paints a picture of a world so very distant from goodness, and He who is goodness.
In his writing and speaking, Bishop Robert Barron frequently references “spiritual physics,” suggestive of the Divine playbook and its fixed set of rules governing our spiritual lives in cause-and-effect fashion. Dante vividly demonstrates these spiritual physics with contrapasso, a reflection of natural law in that every sinful choice has an equal and fitting punishment. “Stuck in the mire they say, ‘Sullen we were up in the sweet air gladdened by the sun, bearing a sluggish smoke within our hearts. Now we are sullen in this black bog here.’ Such is the hymn they gargle in the throat. They cannot get the words out whole and clear” (Canto 7, Lines 121-126). Dante names the sin, evokes its heaviness, and describes its contrapasso, it’s punishment: they are literally stuck in the mire of hell as they were emotionally stuck on earth, unable to intelligibly describe any just source for their melancholy. These equal and fitting contrapasso appear in all nine Circles of Hell, each one depicting the earthly sin and its matching punishment for the unrepentant sinner.
The spiritual physics become more intense as we go deeper. In the 10th ditch of the 8th Circle of Hell, Dante shows us the falsifiers: “Down toward the bottom, where the minister of God on high, Justice infallible, punishes counterfeits who’s sins on earth It enters in its book. No greater gloom did all the sick of Aegina behold, when the air was so full of pestilence” (Canto 29, Lines 55-58). He goes on to describe their punishment: “And I’ve not seen a currycomb so fast scrubbed by the stable boy whose master’s coming, or by one waked against his will to hurry, As did each soul rake himself with the bite of fingernails in the great maddening itch, itch that will never find relief or rest…” (Canto 29, Lines 76-80). The itch for more, driven by falsification on earth, translates to an eternal itch scratched endlessly without satisfaction. Dante’s powerfully sensual descriptions affirms the temporal dissatisfaction in the sin and its eternal consequence.
Sin is Progressively Corrupting
The structure of the Inferno reflects a descending progression into worsening sin. Upper Hell is composed of Circles 2 through 4 describing sins of incontinence, or excessive appetite, resulting in lust, gluttony, avarice, and prodigality. These sins are disordered desires for sex, wealth, power, and prestige – the things of the world that, in moderation, can be good but in sin turn to excess. Dante’s prowess as a poet, insights as a repenting Catholic exiled from his home, and experience as a sinner, reveal themselves in the Inferno. In one story from Francesca, a young lover caught in adulterous lust, we hear: “One day we two were reading for delight about how love had mastered Lancelot; were alone and innocent and felt No cause to fear. And as we read, at times we went pale, as we caught each other’s glance, but we were conquered by one point alone. For when we read that the much-longed-for smile accepted such a gentle lover’s kiss, this man, who nothing will divide from me, trembled to place his lips upon my mouth. A pander was that author, and his book” (Canto 5, Lines 127-137)! Francesca’s tale reveals the danger of human frailty, naively caught in a near-occasion, in which passion overtakes reason, and the brokenness of which all humanity is prone, is revealed. Murdered in the act by her husband, she could not repent and now sits in Hell, doomed to blame love, and the writer of a story, for the choice she made.
From there, the Inferno moves to Middle Hell, composed of Circles 5 through 7, holding those guilty of sins of violence, against others, against oneself, and against God. In the second round of the 7th Circle, we find the spoilers and suicides. The pilgrim Dante plucks off a branch from a tree he encounters only to hear it cry, “Why do you hack at me?” Virgil asks one of the trees how the “soul’s grafted here inside these knobs” and receives this response: “When the ferocious soul that plucks itself from its own body leaves it and departs, judge Minos sends it to his seventh shelf. In the woods it falls, no chosen place. Wherever Fortune’s crossbow slings it, there is puts its roots down like the rankest weed., It shoots into a sapling, a wild plant. The Harpies chew its foliage for their feed…” (Canto 13, Lines 94-100). Dante learns that this tree was once an advisor to King Frederick II, became scorned at court, and was driven to kill himself to escape the shame. The Poet’s description captures the degrading nature of this sin’s corruption in a kind of animalistic domination of the mind. But Dante is not done showing us how sin progressively corrupts.
Lower Hell, Circles 8 and 9, show us sins of the intellect: avarice, fraud, and betrayal. Dante’s characterization of these sins reflects the deepening corruption of darker sin born of malice and intention. The characters, stories, and contrapasso, become increasingly repulsive as we delve further toward Satan’s icy domain at the bottom of the 9th Circle. The 8th Circle presents seducers and panderers, guilty of fraud in their deceits. In the 1st ditch, we learn of Jason the Argonaut who “With acts of love and words of sweetest skill he fooled the pretty Hypsipyle, who’d fooled the rest in leading them to kill. He left her great with child and all alone;” (Canto 18, Lines 91-94) and then drop to the 3rd ditch where those guilty of simony, selling church favors, are reviled, “The things of God should be espoused to righteousness and love, and you Rapacious wolves, you pander them for gold, foul them for silver (Canto 19, Lines 2-5)! Dante takes us further and further into human depravity, demonstrating the darkening of souls and intellect to its most base with contrapasso to match. Canto 21, line 52, tells of punishment for those guilty of accepting bribes: “When they’d harpooned him with a hundred prongs they jeered, “You do your jigs here undercover, so grab the cash in hiding, if you can!”
Thinking back to Saint Benedict’s vision of the Upper Room and its revelation of heaven and earth, we are reminded of this line from Jesus’ Bread of Life discourse in John 6:54, Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day.” By Line 54, Jesus has upped the ante by using the Greek “trogo” as the word for eat – a version that dramatically means “to chew on” or “gnaw on” (https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/the-real-presence-part-two?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss). Now near the very bottom of Hell, we meet Count Ugolino and Archbishop Ruggieri, both betrayers and enemies now trapped together in Antenora, an area of the 9th Circle of Hell devoted to betrayers of nation or party. In life, Count Ugolino was locked in a tower with his young sons and left to starve. Watching them all die over a period of days, Ugolino resorts to cannibalism before he too dies.
Now trapped at the bottom of hell, we see them, “two frozen in one hole in such a way that one man’s head was like the other’s hood, and as a hunk of bread is chewed in hunger, so did the top soul tear his teeth into the other, where the neck adjoins the brain, Just as Tydeus in his spiteful rage gnawed at the temples of his enemy, so did he gnaw the brains, the flesh, the skull” (Canto 32, Lines 125-134). So deeply has sin corrupted these souls, that they are completely cut off from the Triune God, resorting to gnawing on each other in eternal damnation, rather than on the gift of the second person of the Trinity, the Bread of Life. Dante’s special gift is to give us this stark vision as both contrapasso to Ugolino and Ruggierie’s sinful choices, and contrast to Christ’s offer of His body for the redemption of humanity.
Beginning the Climb Up
What’s the point? Returning to Sally’s words, “Jesus wants your heart,” I’m reminded that Dante’s journey through Inferno was only the beginning. Saint Benedict entreats us to listen: to the Word, to each other, and by sign and implication, to the poet Dante. Beatrice’s rescue operation was a Divine intervention in the hope of bringing the pilgrim to Paradiso. Jesus wants the hearts of all people. The facts, figures, structure, characters, and veiled wisdom of The Inferno are complex layers building Dante’s inspired creation of a world and narrative meant to shock, challenge, inspire, and invite, in such a way as to turn our eyes heavenward. The Inferno is a descent on the first leg of a journey in pursuit of truth, toward the ultimate Truth. But rather than Jesus’ truth: I am the way the truth, and the life, the Inferno offers us a warning:
I AM THE WAY INTO THE CITY OF WOE
I AM THE WAY INTO ETERNAL PAIN
I AM THE WAY TO GO AMONG THE LOST
JUSTICE CAUSED MY HIGH ARCHITECT TO MOVE:
DIVINE OMNIPOTENCE CREATED ME,
THE HIGHEST WISDOM, AND THE PRIMAL LOVE.
BEFORE ME THERE WERE NO CREATED THINGS
BUT THOSE THAT LAST FOREVER – AS DO I.
ABANDON ALL HOPE YOU WHO ENTER HERE.
For Dante, there is hope. Despite the layers of sin he experiences, Virgil continues to remind him that they are progressing. God’s great promise of redemption is all the greater from the depths of sin we find in the Inferno. These souls are lost, relegated to a Circle for their particular sin, but in Hell for lack of repentance. For the living, this makes the Inferno a story of hope. Given the imagery and language to evince a new sense of sin and its eternal consequences, we are armed to understand and share the Good News with a renewed relevance to a world who has forgotten about the weight of sin, and the insidious effects of its corrupting nature. From here, we’re ready to begin the long journey home.