EMCrit FOAM Feed

Podcast 144 – The PROPPR trial with John Holcomb


Listen Later


Today, we discuss the PROPPR Trial with its lead author, John Holcomb, MD. This was an RCT of trauma patients with severe hemorrhage. It pitted 1:1:1 matched product transfusion with a 1:1:2 control group. Dr. Holcomb is a Trauma Surgeon at University of Texas, Houston. He spent decades in the military as a surgeon before continuing his career in Houston.

This podcast is coming out a week early, but it is too good to wait!
The Study
PROPPR Trial from JAMA
Study Summary
As per their routine, the Bottom Line Review summarized the study beautifully:

Sorry, you do not have iframe working. Click here to go to the article.
Questions I discussed with Dr. Holcomb

* If you had to give the elevator pitch for the take-home message of the trial, what would it be?
* The doubters may say that the control group in the study should have been 1:3 (plasma:rbc) or even no fixed ratio, but solely an INR/Plt lab based approach. They may say that PROPPR shows 1:1:1 is as good as or better than 1:1:2, but may not be better than a much lower rate of plasma and PLT transfusion. What do you say to this line of commentary?
* The trigger for massive transfusion in the PROPPR trial was ABC>=2 or clinician judgment. Do you bother with scores in your personal practice? Should we be using them?
* In the 1:1:1 group, platelets were given up front (0 unit mark). In the 1:1:2 group, they were only given after 9 units of product. What was the rationale for this? Do you think it might have made a difference?
* It seems the 1:1:2 group played catch up for plasma over the next 24 hours. Do you think this supports the contention that early 1:1:1 may spare the need for products down the road, especially in light of the fact that exsanguination deaths were an early phenomenon.
* Median RBCs were 9 units over 24 hours, which means over half of the patients did not receive the 10 units of RBC that traditionally define Massive Transfusion. Should we redefine MT? What is the point at which it was beneficial to have matched plasma/plt to RBCs.
* This trial was not designed to look at this question, but I want to know what you think. In 2015, should we be using the empiric ratios of the PROPPR trial or should we be switching to a visco-elastic (TEG/TEM) based strategy?
* Let’s do some rapid fire… Aside from the randomized intervention, the trial was pragmatic, so I would love to hear your personal feelings and practice on:
*BP goal
*TXA
*Cryoprecipitate
*Crystalloids
* Most studies have a back story—something all of the researchers know, but is not reflected in the word-trimmed, published version. What are we not seeing in the published form of the PROPPR study?

Some key points from the discussion

* Our current definitions of massive transfusion are outdated. Better may be the Critical Administration Threshold--if you give 3 units of blood in any 1 hour period, it is a massive transfusion. But...
* Dr. Holcomb doesn't wait for the 3 unit threshold. At his shop, they try to make the 1st unit transfused plasma or platelets and start matched transfusion from that point forward.
* In the PROPPR trial, only about 2/3 of the patients received TXA, but CRASH2 indications would have had all of them receive it. Dr. Holcomb uses TEG to decide, and wants to see more RCTS (they are being done) to better clarify the role of TXA. For more on that though,
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

EMCrit FOAM FeedBy Scott D. Weingart, MD FCCM

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

1,839 ratings


More shows like EMCrit FOAM Feed

View all
Emergency Medicine Cases by Dr. Anton Helman

Emergency Medicine Cases

538 Listeners

The FlightBridgeED Podcast by Long Pause Media | FlightBridgeED

The FlightBridgeED Podcast

385 Listeners

Core EM - Emergency Medicine Podcast by Core EM

Core EM - Emergency Medicine Podcast

251 Listeners

The Resus Room by Simon Laing, Rob Fenwick & James Yates

The Resus Room

104 Listeners

EM Clerkship by Zack Olson, MD ; Mike Estephan, MD ; Maddie Watts, MD

EM Clerkship

808 Listeners

The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast by The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast

The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast

3,336 Listeners

Emergency Medical Minute by Emergency Medical Minute

Emergency Medical Minute

257 Listeners

Heavy Lies the Helmet by Mike Boone, Dan Rauh, & Dr. Amanda Humphries

Heavy Lies the Helmet

257 Listeners

Core IM | Internal Medicine Podcast by Core IM Team

Core IM | Internal Medicine Podcast

1,095 Listeners

The Internet Book of Critical Care Podcast by Adam Thomas & Josh Farkas

The Internet Book of Critical Care Podcast

694 Listeners

Cardionerds: A Cardiology Podcast by CardioNerds

Cardionerds: A Cardiology Podcast

427 Listeners

Critical Care Scenarios by Brandon Oto, PA-C, FCCM and Bryan Boling, DNP, ACNP, FCCM

Critical Care Scenarios

249 Listeners

The World’s Okayest Medic Podcast by Mike Carunchio

The World’s Okayest Medic Podcast

166 Listeners

EMS 20/20 by Long Pause Media | FlightBridgeED

EMS 20/20

816 Listeners

Critical Care Time by Critical Care Time Podcast

Critical Care Time

233 Listeners