Send us a text

This week on Sip, Spill & Solve, Kiki is joined by a very special guest — her daughter Kelsey — for a brand-new format we’re calling Read & React. Kiki reads the entire case live on the mic, and Kelsey reacts in real time… which means chaos, confusion, mocktail commentary, and a LOT of unfiltered moments.

Together they dive into the chilling, bizarre, and little-known case of Sarah Jane Harvey, a quiet woman from Rhyl, Wales whose cupboard hid a horrifying secret for over 20 years. When her son opened the locked space while Sarah was in the hospital, he found a fully mummified woman wrapped in blankets — with a stocking tied around her neck.

Who was the victim?
How did she end up there?
And what did Sarah truly know?

Kiki leads the story while Kelsey responds with genuine “WHAT?!” reactions that will make you feel like you're sitting right there with them.

Also in this episode:
⭐ A sparkling holiday mocktail taste-test (non-Christmas, just vibes)
⭐ The Toilet Paper Bandit — your Dumb Criminal of the Week
⭐ Theories, laughter, shock, and more questions than answers

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

Hollywood fame, fatal attraction, and a marriage built on lies — this week, Kiki and Jeannie unravel the shocking murder of Bonny Lee Bakley and the explosive trial of actor Robert Blake. 💋

From Bonny’s long trail of celebrity scams to the night she was found shot in Blake’s car outside a Studio City restaurant, this episode dives deep into one of Hollywood’s most twisted true crime love stories. Was it revenge, desperation, or something darker?

Join us as we sip, spill, and solve this scandal that blurred the line between fame and fatal obsession.

🎙️ Keywords: Robert Blake, Bonny Lee Bakley, Hollywood murder case, true crime podcast, Sip Spill and Solve, celebrity scandal, unsolved murder, noir crime story.

As always thank you to those other podcasts and news articles that help us in our research.  Special thanks to The World of Crime and Dearly Departed Tours With Scott.

Our condolences also to the family of Jesse Farber, as they finally were able to recover his remains. 

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

keywords

Halloween, spooky stories, True or Boo, wine, Kiki Fackler, Sip Spill and Spook, ghost stories, urban legends, Halloween traditions, haunted tales

summary

In this Halloween-themed episode of Sip, Spill, and Spook, Kiki Fackler and her friend engage in a fun game called 'True or Boo,' where they share spooky stories and try to guess which ones are true or made up. The conversation flows through various chilling tales, including urban legends, haunted hotels, and the infamous Candy Man, all while enjoying cozy wine. The episode captures the spirit of Halloween with laughter, suspense, and nostalgic reflections on childhood fears and traditions.

takeaways

• The game 'True or Boo' involves guessing the truth behind spooky stories.
• Warm spiced wine is perfect for Halloween gatherings.
• The Bunny Man is a real urban legend from Virginia.
• The Trick-or-Treat murder case highlights the dark side of Halloween.
• Haunted hotels can be a source of real-life horror stories.
• The Candy Man case is a chilling reminder of parental betrayal.
• Halloween traditions often stem from urban legends and folklore.
• Sharing spooky stories is a fun way to celebrate Halloween.
• Nostalgia plays a big role in how we remember Halloween as children.
• Wine and spooky tales make for a cozy Halloween night.

titles

• Sip, Spill, and Spook: Halloween Edition
• True or Boo: A Spooky Game Night

Sound Bites

• "Our job is to guess which one is fake."
• "This is a cozy wine to get."
• "Happy haunting! Cheers!"

Chapters

00:00
Sip, Spill, and Spook: Halloween Edition

02:41
True or Boo: The Game Begins

06:40
Spooky Stories: The Bunny Man and Trick-or-Treat Murders

11:39
Haunted Hotels and the Candy House

15:46
The Candy Man: A True Halloween Horror

19:12
Halloween Plans and Reflections

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

Thanks to the Morbid podcast for all their interesting observations!

keywords

Lizzie Borden, true crime, cocktails, murder mystery, history, spooky stories, podcast, family dynamics, investigation, trial

takeaways

• Lizzie Borden's family life was fraught with tension and resentment.
• The Witch's Brew Margarita is a fun Halloween cocktail.
• The Borden house was cramped and shared by four adults.
• Lizzie and her sister were spinsters involved in charity work.
• The murders occurred on August 4, 1892, while Emma was away.
• Lizzie's alibi was questionable during the investigation.
• The police were at a picnic, leading to delays in the investigation.
• Lizzie was acquitted due to lack of evidence and societal biases.
• The case remains a topic of speculation and intrigue today.
• Lizzie's life after the trial was marked by controversy and mystery.

summary

In this episode, Kiki and Karen delve into the chilling story of Lizzie Borden, exploring her family dynamics, the infamous murders, and the subsequent trial that captivated the nation. They also share a spooky cocktail recipe, the Witch's Brew Margarita, perfect for Halloween. The conversation weaves through the historical context of the Borden household, the investigation, and the lasting legacy of Lizzie Borden, making for a compelling mix of true crime and festive fun.

titles

• Unraveling the Lizzie Borden Mystery
• Cocktails and Crime: The Borden Case

Sound Bites

• "The murders occurred on August 4, 1892."
• "Lizzie was acquitted due to lack of evidence."
• "The case remains a topic of speculation today."

Chapters

00:00
Introduction to Sips Mill & Spook

41:55
NEWCHAPTER

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

This week on Sip, Spill & Solve, Kiki and Jeannie head to Georgetown, D.C. to climb one of the most famous—and haunted—staircases in movie history: The Exorcist Steps.

Built in 1895 and made infamous by the 1973 horror classic The Exorcist, these steep, shadowy stairs have seen more than just cinematic screams. Locals whisper about eerie chills, phantom footsteps, and the feeling of being watched—long after the cameras stopped rolling.

The girls sip a bold, blood-red Cabernet while spilling fun film trivia, spooky lore, and a few personal confessions about fear, faith, and fall cardio gone wrong.

🍷 Two girlfriends. One bottle. Zero qualifications.
🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you sip your stories.
🔗 RSS Feed: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2471673.rss

📸 Follow: @sip.spill.solve

keywords

Sip Spill Spook, Exorcist Steps, Georgetown, haunted places, horror movies, spooky drinks, October podcast, ghost stories, horror film history, listener interaction

summary

In this episode of Sip, Spill, and Spook, hosts Jeannie and Kiki explore the haunted Exorcist Steps in Georgetown, DC, while sipping on a cozy hot apple cider. They delve into the history of the steps, their connection to the iconic horror film 'The Exorcist', and share personal experiences with horror movies. The conversation flows into listener engagement, inviting stories and experiences related to haunted places.

takeaways

• The Exorcist Steps are a significant haunted location in Georgetown, DC.
• The hosts enjoy pairing spooky themes with seasonal drinks.
• The history of the Exorcist Steps includes a politician's murder and cinematic fame.
• Personal horror movie experiences can shape one's perception of fear.
• The Exorcist film has a legacy of eerie occurrences during its production.
• The hosts discuss the impact of classic horror films on modern audiences.
• Listener engagement is encouraged for sharing spooky experiences.
• The conversation highlights the beauty of Georgetown, especially in the fall.
• The hosts reflect on their differing tastes in horror and thriller genres.
• The episode emphasizes the importance of sharing listener stories for community building.

Sound Bites

• "Two girlfriends, one bottle, and zero qualifications."
• "I have still not seen that movie."
• "I think it's a genetic component that you have."

Chapters

00:00
Introduction to Spooky Sips

02:47
The Exorcist Steps: A Haunted History

05:00
Cinematic Legends and Urban Legends

07:47
Personal Horror Stories and Movie Memories

10:18
The Haunting of Georgetown: Experiences and Anecdotes

13:06
Conclusion and Listener Engagement

23:09
NEWCHAPTER

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

The One With Slag Pile Annie

Sip, Spill & Solve – Episode 18

Grab your glass and your ghost stories — we’re heading to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, home of steel, smoke, and one legendary spirit who never clocked out: Slag Pile Annie.

According to mill lore, Annie was a tough-as-nails worker who met her end deep in the tunnels beneath the Jones & Laughlin Steel Works. Decades later, steelworkers swore she still showed up for her shift — same coveralls, same red bandanna — whispering,

“I can’t get killed… I’m already dead.”

This week, Kiki and Jeannie sip their newest autumn cocktail, the Golden Harvest Fizz — a cozy mix of apple cider, caramel vodka, and ginger ale with sliced apples on top — while unraveling the haunting legend that fuses Pittsburgh grit with ghostly lore.

So pour yourself a glass, cue the eerie glow of the furnaces, and join us as we ask: was Annie real, or just forged from the fire of mill-town memory?

🍷 Two girlfriends. One bottle. Zero qualifications.
🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you sip your stories.
🔗 RSS Feed: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2471673.rss

📸 Follow us on Instagram: @sip-spill-solve

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

It’s The One With the Hanover Haunting! 👻🍷 This week we’re diving into the eerie tale of the Maple Street house in Hanover, Pennsylvania—one of the most talked-about hauntings in the state. Was it truly paranormal… or just small-town legend run wild?

And because every ghost story deserves a spooky sip, we’re mixing up our new fall favorite: the Caramel Mule cocktail 🥂—sweet, spicy, and just a little bit haunting itself.

🎧 Join us as we sip, spill, and solve our way through Hanover’s most infamous haunted house.

🍸 Cocktail Pairing: The Caramel Mule

• 2 oz caramel vodka (or regular vodka + splash of caramel syrup)
• ½ oz lime juice (fresh squeezed)
• Top with ginger beer
• Garnish with an apple slice or cinnamon stick

Serve in a copper mug over ice—best enjoyed with ghost stories and girlfriends.

Read the book! Hanover Haunting, The DeAnna Simpson Story by Joni Mayhan

https://amzn.to/42nvqqe

Keywords

hauntings, paranormal, Hanover PA, ghost stories, supernatural, spooky, cocktail recipes, dark history, personal experiences, mental health

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

Two girlfriends. One bottle. Zero qualifications.

In this week’s episode of Sip, Spill & Solve, we’re shaking up a Bee’s Knees cocktail 🐝 and diving into two wild stories:

🍷 Dumb Criminals: The man who got so drunk he literally joined the search party looking for himself. (Yes, really.)

🕵️ Uncorked Mysteries: The unsolved murder of Ivan Darling in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania — a decades-old cold case that still haunts the community and begs the question: Who killed Ivan Darling?

From hilarious to haunting, this one has it all. Pour a glass, press play, and join us as we sip, spill, and say: what the hell did we just listen to?

✨ Stay suspicious — and don’t get Burg-e-ler’d.

📲 Follow along:

• Instagram: @sip-spill-solve
  
  
• Facebook: facebook.com/sip-spill-solve
  
  
• Email: [email protected]
  
  

#SipSpillSolve #TrueCrimePodcast #DumbCriminals #UnsolvedMystery #StaySuspicious

We want to give a shout out to the podcast Unsolved In PA for their episode "Murder on York Street, The Christmas Death Of Ivan Darling."

As always, if you have any information please contact the local authorities, (or don't if you think they don't have their s*#t together, then DM us!)

For this particular episode it would be  717-334-1168, or after hours at 717-334-8101.” 

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

🎙️ Two girlfriends. One bottle. Zero qualifications.

In this week’s Wine, Whine & WTH episode of Sip, Spill & Solve, we dive into one of the internet’s wildest true crime conspiracies — the Garth Brooks serial killer theory (allegedly 😉). From Tom Segura’s viral jokes to TikTok speculation, fan podcasts, and even lawsuits, we’re unpacking how a country superstar became the subject of one of the strangest rumors in pop culture.

Is it all just internet meme fuel, or is there something darker hiding beneath the cowboy hat? 👀

Grab your glass, press play, and get ready to sip, spill, and say: what the hell did we just listen to?

✨ Stay suspicious — and don’t get Burg-e-ler’d.

📲 Follow along:

• Instagram: @sipspillsolve
  
  
• Facebook: facebook.com/sip-spill-solve
  
  
• Email: [email protected]
  
  

#SipSpillSolve #WineWhineWTH #TrueCrimePodcast #StaySuspicious

keywords

Garth Brooks, Chris Gaines, conspiracy theories, missing persons, celebrity allegations, true crime, podcast, wine, friendship, pop culture

takeaways

• The episode explores the bizarre conspiracy theories surrounding Garth Brooks.
• Chris Gaines is introduced as Garth Brooks' alter ego, raising questions about identity.
• Allegations against Brooks highlight the darker side of celebrity culture.
• Coincidences between Brooks' tour dates and missing persons cases are discussed.
• The hosts express their skepticism about the validity of the conspiracy theories.
• The nature of fame can complicate accusations and public perception.
• Community support for missing persons is emphasized as crucial.
• The conversation reflects on the legal implications of celebrity allegations.
• The hosts share personal anecdotes and insights throughout the discussion.
• The episode concludes with a call for awareness and advocacy for missing persons.

titles

• Unraveling the Garth Brooks Conspiracy
• The Dark Side of Fame: Garth Brooks Edition

Sound Bites

• "I just feel weird about this one."
• "I just want to know what happened."
• "I have friends in low places."

Chapters

00:00
Introduction to the Episode

02:31
The Garth Brooks Conspiracy Begins

05:48
Chris Gaines: The Alter Ego

09:33
Allegations and Controversies

13:08
Coincidences and Missing Persons

20:20
Theories and Speculations

26:14
Legal Battles and Public Perception

30:04
Closing Thoughts and Reflections

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders

Send us a text

Episode 14 Description

It’s Cocktail Confessions time, and this week we’re pouring the Royal Apple — crisp, cozy, and just dangerous enough to make you spill your secrets. 👑🍎

Then we dive into two stories that prove bad notes never end well:

🧻 Dumb Criminals: Meet the Toilet Paper Boyfriend — a North Carolina man who thought TP-ing his ex’s house and leaving a threatening note was a good idea. (Spoiler: it wasn’t. Police were not impressed.)

👁️ Uncorked Mysteries: We open up the chilling case of The Watcher — the New Jersey family who bought their dream home, only to start receiving anonymous, terrifying letters from someone who claimed to be watching their every move.

We’re not your normal sleuths — we’re two girlfriends, sipping cocktails, giggling way too loud, and absolutely unqualified to be doing this. But that’s kind of the fun.

🎧 Pour a Royal Apple, press play, and remember: Stay suspicious… and don’t get Burg-e-ler’d.

#SipSpillSolve #TheWatcher #TrueCrimePodcast #CocktailConfessions #ToiletPaperBoyfriend

keywords

cocktail confessions, dumb criminals, The Watcher, mystery, true crime, podcast, psychological thriller, letters, North Carolina, New Jersey

summary

In this episode of Sip, Spill, and Solve, the hosts dive into a mix of light-hearted cocktail confessions and a chilling true crime mystery. They start with a humorous story about a North Carolina man who toilet papered his ex's house, leading to his arrest. The conversation then shifts to a darker theme as they explore the unsettling mystery of 'The Watcher,' a stalker who sent threatening letters to a family in their new home in New Jersey. The hosts discuss the psychological impact of the letters and the family's subsequent struggles, concluding with listener engagement and a call for cocktail recipes.

takeaways

• The episode features a mix of humor and true crime.
• The hosts share a cocktail recipe called Royal Apple Cocktail.
• A North Carolina man was arrested for toilet papering his ex's house.
• The story of 'The Watcher' involves unsettling letters sent to a family.
• The letters contained creepy messages about 'young blood.'
• The Broaddus family never moved into their dream home due to the letters.
• The psychological impact of the letters was significant for the family.
• The hosts encourage listeners to share their own cocktail recipes.
• The episode highlights the importance of community and listener engagement.
• The conversation blends light-heartedness with serious themes.

titles

• Cocktail Confessions and Creepy Letters
• From Toilet Paper to Terror: The Watcher

Sound Bites

• "It was psychological warfare."
• "I would not live in the house."
• "We should do a road trip. New Jersey!"

Chapters

00:00
Introduction to Sip, Spill, and Solve

02:56
The Toilet Paper Boyfriend: A Dumb Criminal Story

06:47
Uncorked Mystery: The Watcher Letters

25:13
The Psychological Impact of The Watcher

27:34
Listener Engagement and Closing Remarks

29:37
NEWCHAPTER

- 💀 Girlfriends by day, wildly unqualified detectives by night.
📲 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook: @sip-spill-solve
📬 Got tips, wine, or true crime theories? Email: [email protected]
🍷 New episodes every Wednesday—where the dumb meets the disturbing.

Producer Madylyn Zeiders