We break down their cases, the competition, and the metrics voters see. Winn led NL shortstops in Outs Above Average (+21) before a late-season injury, while Pete Crow-Armstrong, Victor Scott II, and Jacob Young headline a loaded CF group.

We also touch on Mookie Betts and Nick Allen in the SS race, plus former Cardinal Tommy Pham and Cubs catcher Carson Kelly making the finalist lists. Winners are announced Sunday, Nov 2 on ESPN.