BT & Sal are fired up after discovering actress Sydney Sweeney—who recently appeared on their show—was spotted at the World Series wearing a Dodger jersey, despite explicitly refusing to name a favorite team to the hosts! Sal feels personally betrayed by the "A-List Betrayal," sparking a massive debate about whether she was being genuine or simply following a PR strategy.

The discussion quickly devolves into a separate, equally fiery take from Sal on Shohei Ohtani. Sal minimizes Ohtani's accomplishment as a two-way player, calling the "two jobs" claim overrated and questioning if his impressive moments are only impressive because of the anomaly. BT vehemently disagrees, arguing Ohtani is "one of one" and historically unprecedented, leading to a huge argument over whether Ohtani is more impressive than Aaron Judge, Babe Ruth, or even Tiger Woods and Mike Tyson.