Melissa starts her RPS comeback tour this week with one throw for the win! She tells Sarah about one of the first main stream true crime media circuses and the story of Joey Buttafuoco and his Long Island Lolita, Amy Fisher. Sarah talks about the abduction of 7 year old Steven Stayner in 1972.

The girls are back with more of their unedited, off script moments. Enjoyyyyyy!

It takes 3 rounds for Sarah to be today's champion for RPS. She tells Melissa about the Yosemite killer, Cary Stayner. Melissa then tells Sarah about a man who thought he could offset earthquakes with human sacrifice, Herbert Mullin. 

Sarah takes out Melissa with one throw! She tells Melissa about Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper. Melissa then shares the story of one Freeway Killer, William Bonin. 

This week there's no RPS since Melissa did a solo ep last week... tag along to hear the devastating tale of the Soham murders. 

Sarah win's a 5 round battle of RPS this week but Melissa steals the show and presents a story so twisted that the girl's decide to leave it as a solo story day. Melissa tells Sarah the story of the Kindly Killer, and most prolific British Serial Killer, Dennis Nilsen. 

Melissa  delivers a decisive victory in RPS and shares the almost impossible to believe story of deadly doctor, Maynard Muntzing II in Ohio. Sarah continues her vampire obsession and tells Melissa about the demented vampire Rod Ferrell and his murder rampage in Florida. 

Sarah wins RPS in one throw and tells Melissa the tragic tale of lottery winner, Abraham Shakespeare. Melissa shares the mysterious disappearance and murder of the Flactif family from Grand Bornand, France.

Melissa comes out swinging... there's talk of unsportsmanlike behavior but it's settled quickly with Melissa taking the win today. She tells Sarah the heartbreaking story of Kentucky teenager, Jessica Dishon, who was taken too soon and a cold case for too long. Sarah shares the exploits of suspected mafia hitman, Richard Kuklinski, otherwise known as the 'Iceman Killer.'

Sarah slides her back to a RPS win. She tells Melissa the listener suggested story of the disappearance of Heather Elvis from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Melissa then tells Sarah about the abduction and murder of New York student Imette St. Guillen.