Melissa ends Sarah's streak of 3 with one throw. She tells Sarah about the murder of Pam Candelario in Colorado. Sarah shares the heartbreaking story of the disappearance and murder of Joanna Yeates from England. 

Sarah takes the 3 peat in RPS. She tells Melissa about the suspected mafia hit on Don Bolles... THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN PLANNED IN THEIR GRANDFATHER'S BAR??? Melissa tells Sarah the twisted tale that took the life of 13 year old Hillary Norskog.

Sarah crushes Melissa in one throw. She tells Melissa about the ongoing murder investigation of Egypt Covington in Van Buren Township, Michigan. Melissa takes Sarah on an insane tale of intrigue with the murders of Sandy Bird and Marty Anderson in Emporia, Kansas.

Sarah gets her act together and finally ends Melissa's RPS streak after 5 weeks. She tells Melissa about the murdered beauty queen Tara Grinstead from Georgia. Melissa shares the story of murdered woman, Alyce Seff in German Village, Ohio. 

Melissa is officially the new world champ of RPS with 5 straight wins. Suck it haters. She tells Sarah about the twisted tale from Washington, the murder of Lisa Carlson. Sarah shares an disturbing story of best friends turned criminals with the story of Pauline Parker and Juliet Hulme from New Zealand. 

Melissa is elite, she’s on a 4 time RPS win hot streak. She tells Sarah the story of Georgia’s largest mass murder to date, the Woolfolk Family Massacre. Sarah shares the heart breaking story of a young artist, Kristin Huggins, who went missing in Trenton, NJ in 1992.  

Melissa stays camp champ at RPS. She tells Sarah the sad story of Linda Watson, a missing Tucson mother, and her own mother’s never ending quest to find her. Sarah shares the story of missing Connecticut mother Helle Craft, and what it took for the police to catch her killer. And then they both agreed to never get married because men are obvs cray. 

Melissa’s on a heater and wins RPS. She tells Sarah about the insane case of Patricia Stallings, a mother from Missouri who was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of her newborn son, but after a surprise pregnancy in prison the case takes an unexpected turn. Sarah tells Melissa about the almost unbelievable tale of Angela Diaz from Anaheim, CA.

The girls battle it out but ultimately Sarah bests Melissa at Knife, Pumpkin, Tombstone. Then Sarah shares the haunting Liske Family murders from Ohio on Halloween 2010. Melissa takes it back a little bit to 1957 California and The Trick-Or-Treat-Murder of Peter Fabiano. 

Melissa takes RPS today in one battle. She tells Sarah about a local Arizona murder from the 70s of armored van drivers Russell Dempsey and Cecil Newkirk. Sarah goes in depth on the White House Farm Murders from Essex, England.