Blah blah blah Melissa doesn’t win RPS. Sarah tells an insane murder and survival story out of California that happened just a few months ago. Melissa fangirls over Lt. Joe Kenda again and tells another tale of a bizarre murder in Colorado that leaves Sarah shocked. 

Sarah wins RPS, we get it. Sarah tells us about the insane disappearance of Joan Risch, the missing Massachusetts mother from 1961. Melissa shares a love triangle murder story out of Missouri that sees Randy Stone murdered in his office by the person you’d least expect.

Melissa can't pull off the threepeat and loses at RPS. Sarah tells the incredibly depressing story of Charles "Charlie" Starkweather's murder spree in 1950's Nebraska with not so innocent Caril Fugate. Melissa counters with the tale of Valerie Pape, the French murderess in Scottsdale from the 90's. 

Melissa starts a streak by winning RPS in one throw, and tells Sarah about a crime passionnel in 1950’s France. Sarah shares the disturbing story of Robert Hansen, the Butcher Baker of Alaska.

Melissa starts her comeback and wins RPS in one throw. She then tells Sarah about the rarest type of criminal who apparently Sarah has already reported on twice. Buzzkill. Sarah shares the story of our nation’s first murder trial aka the liberty behind deliberation. 

Melissa at least hangs for six rounds but Sarah wins AGAIN at RPS. There’s suspicions of a conspiracy. Sarah tells Melissa a story about Sharon Kinne, aka to us Share-Bare, the psychoctic murderess. Melissa then shares a shocking story from Down Under about a warrior of a woman, Maria Korp. 

Melissa can almost count how many fingers are on one hand. Sarah moves to 4-1 in the RPS world series championships and tells Melissa about the Teacup Poisoner from across the pond, Graham Young. Melissa rounds out the unplanned poisoning episode with the murder of the hopeless romantic, Linda Curry. 

Sarah continues her streak of RPS and shares the story of the Pied Piper of Tucson, and professional wig wearer Charles Schmid. Melissa tells Sarah about the meth bender murders of John Painter and Barbara Martin.

Sarah wins RPS again and tells the tale of Nannie Doss, also known as the Giggling Granny/The Lonely Hearts Killer. Melissa shares the story of a workplace feud that leads to the murder of Dr. Brian Stidham.

Sarah wins rock paper scissors this week and tells Melissa the awful story of the Canadian Bathtub Girls. Melissa then shares her deep love of Lt. Joe Kenda and tells one of his cases about the murder of a Colorado suburban mother, Betty Limbrick.