The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle reacts to Brian Cashman’s grim updates regarding the recovery timelines for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. He debates the Yankees' recent 'death spiral' without their superstars, considers a potential trade for Rafael Devers, and revisits his radio roots with a nostalgic piece for Steve Somers.

01:20 - Remembering Bonnie Tyler

05:02 - Mets Care Or Not Care

08:35 - Cashman Backs Aaron Boone

12:20 - Judge And Stanton Updates

19:00 - Yankees In Death Spiral

23:01 - Trading For Rafael Devers

28:40 - 2008 Mets Nostalgia Trip

32:30 - Anthony Volpe Roster Debate

37:40 - Firing Cashman And Boone

Mac revisits a nostalgic 2008 radio segment featuring Johan Santana's shutout performance before engaging in a heated debate with callers about the Yankees. He argues that Anthony Volpe should be benched in favor of Jose Caballero due to prolonged offensive struggles. The discussion also critiques Brian Cashman’s roster construction, specifically comparing the Giancarlo Stanton trade to missed opportunities with Christian Yelich and Bryce Harper.

01:00 - Reliving Santana's 2008 Gem

07:07 - Case for Benching Volpe

12:22 - Cashman and Boone Accountability

17:28 - Evaluating the Stanton Trade

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman react to Brian Cashman’s discouraging updates on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton's health. They explore the Yankees' recent struggles and discuss why acquiring Rafael Devers could provide the necessary offensive boost.

01:00 - Bonnie Tyler Reminiscence

04:55 - Mets Care or Not Care

09:54 - Cashman Backs Aaron Boone

13:25 - Judge and Stanton Injury Updates

21:55 - Rafael Devers Trade Ideas

C-Mac evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive struggles and the significant lack of production from the catching position. He analyzes the debate between starting Anthony Volpe or Oswaldo Cabrera at shortstop while addressing the team's high strikeout rate compared to recent World Series champions.

01:00 - Highlander Movie Discussion

02:43 - Yankees Catching Upgrade Needed

06:33 - Debating Yankee Strikeout Rates

13:53 - Volpe vs Cabrera Debate

16:48 - Bellinger And Mets Update

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees' much-needed series finale victory over the Rays and explains why this wasn't just another win. From Ryan McMahon's game-changing 12-pitch at-bat to Ben Rice's monster series, Chris breaks down the biggest positives and why Yankees fans shouldn't dismiss them. He also clashes with callers who insist the Yankees still aren't contenders, discusses the bullpen, Aaron Judge's injury update from Brian Cashman, and why the upcoming series in Washington is now critical.

Chris McMonigle reacts to the Yankees' historic strikeout streak and addresses rumors surrounding Anthony Volpe's alleged refusal to move to second base. They analyze the Mets' frustrating high-scoring loss, evaluate potential trade deadline targets like Tarik Skubal, and discuss the culture shift expected at Giants training camp.

02:02 - New York Baseball Struggles

07:28 - Volpe Position Change Rumors

13:04 - Shortstop Decision: Volpe vs Cabrera

24:42 - T-Mac's Personal Anecdotes

31:40 - Yankees Lineup vs Rays

16:10 - Tarik Skubal Trade Analysis

25:18 - Reinventing the Wednesday Wheel

38:34 - Volpe Responds to Rumors

14:43 - Cabrera's At-Bat Explanation

27:38 - Giants Camp Culture Shift

On The Carton Show, Chris McMonigle addresses the historic strikeout issues plaguing the Yankees and the controversy over Anthony Volpe’s rumored refusal to change positions. He critiques the organization's loyalty to struggling prospects and the lack of production from the bottom of the lineup during a critical stretch.

01:20 - New York Baseball Recap

05:10 - Yankees Historic Strikeout Crisis

11:11 - Anthony Volpe Position Rumors

15:00 - Future of Yankees Shortstop

20:06 - Trade Deadline Pitching Needs

23:58 - Grisham and Verdugo Struggles

28:01 - Fan Calls on Prospects

Chris McMonigle analyzes the Yankees' decision to bring Anthony Volpe back to the lineup and evaluates the team's need for starting pitching help like Tarik Skubal. They critique the Mets' recent defensive embarrassment and the broader issue of player accountability under Aaron Boone. The conversation also explores the psychological toll of playing in New York and Juan Soto's standout individual performance amidst a losing season.

01:20 - Parenting and 90s Rock

04:44 - NBA 2K Obsessions

10:51 - Caballero Plate Games

14:16 - Tarik Skubal Trade Talk

17:39 - Volpe and Mental Pressure

22:50 - Boone and Team Accountability

30:34 - Yankees Rays Lineup

37:10 - Mets Defensive Meltdown

45:47 - Keith Hernandez Musings

Chris McMonigle addresses Anthony Volpe's firm denial of rumors reported by Joel Sherman and Michael Kay regarding a refused position change. They analyze the impact of injuries to stars like Carlos Rodón and Gerrit Cole while debating the pursuit of Tarik Skubal as the trade deadline approaches.

01:20 - Yankees Rays Series

08:47 - Injury Impact Debate

12:37 - Strikeout Performance Analysis

20:44 - Tarik Skubal Trade Value

23:48 - Wednesday Wheel Game Reimagined

38:27 - Anthony Volpe Denies Rumors

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' roster needs and the potential for a blockbuster trade to acquire Tarik Skubal. He criticizes Jose Caballero for a controversial plate appearance where the player dropped his bat mid-count and debates the true impact of the team's high strikeout totals. The discussion also highlights the importance of Gerrit Cole's performance in the upcoming series against the Tampa Bay Rays.

01:25 - NFL Trivia Prodigy

04:40 - Giants Culture Shock

08:03 - Tarik Skubal Market

15:44 - Caballero Bat Drop

21:35 - Yankees Trade Strategy

25:48 - Hunter Goodman Potential

16:55 - Gerrit Cole Tonight

21:10 - Strikeout Impact Debate