The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

McMonigle and Carton debate the Knicks' dominance over the Cavaliers following a soul-taking Game 1 victory. They honor retiring board op Eddie Scazzari, though Craig questions the sincerity of the tribute. Discussions also touch on Aaron Judge's struggles, various 80s sitcom stars, and a medical emergency in the studio.

01:20 - Craig Carton Sick

04:51 - Knicks Cavaliers Game Two

14:25 - TV And Sitcom Talk

20:40 - Eddie Scazzari WFAN Retirement

25:45 - Radio Career Paths

33:50 - Mike Brown Future

39:00 - Tunnel Vomit Story

44:00 - Music And Celebrities

47:30 - Russini Patriots Rumors

They discuss the frustrating nature of the New York Mets’ $370 million rebuild and the legendary called shot of Babe Ruth. The conversation shifts to debunking the methods of Oz the Mentalist and a hilarious encounter with Islanders owner John Ledecky.

01:55 - The Mets’ Frustrating Rebuild

10:44 - Babe Ruth’s Called Shot

18:10 - Cavaliers Fan Takes Umbrage

22:51 - Restroom Etiquette & Hygiene

29:07 - Debunking Oz the Mentalist

33:05 - Magic Secrets Revealed

47:32 - John Ledecky’s Sushi Habits

56:11 - Hockey Players & Golf

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle evaluate the New York Yankees' lineup changes following a knee injury to Trent Grisham and the emergence of J.C. Escarra on The Carton Show. They examine the legacy of Jalen Brunson with the New York Knicks and are joined by John Fanta to break down the team's playoff dominance over the Cleveland Cavaliers.

01:30 - Yankees Injury News

05:50 - Jeter Contract History

13:30 - Sushi And Dining Stories

20:10 - Jalen Brunson Superstar Rise

28:30 - John Fanta Cavs Preview

37:45 - NBA Coaching Critiques

46:15 - Yankees And AL East

The conversation focuses on the Knicks' playoff run and the debate over Mike Brown's coaching versus Tom Thibodeau's tenure. They evaluate Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s performance and baserunning errors while discussing Brian Cashman's legacy with the Yankees. The segment also reflects on the tragic passing of NASCAR legend Kyle Busch at age 41.

01:26 - Knicks Game 2 Preview

07:53 - Mike Brown Coaching Impact

14:01 - Jazz Chisholm Baserunning Mistakes

17:37 - Yankees Front Office Debate

26:43 - Tragic Kyle Busch Update

31:38 - Jalen Brunson Superstar Rise

WFAN’s Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the unbelievable rise of Jalen Brunson and how everyone completely underestimated what he would become for the New York Knicks.

The guys discuss how mocked the Knicks were for signing Brunson away from Dallas, why Leon Rose deserves massive credit, and whether Brunson is already one of the greatest acquisitions in New York sports history alongside names like Mark Messier, Reggie Jackson, Alex Rodriguez, Keith Hernandez, & more.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by John Fanta to break down the Knicks’ shocking comeback win over Cleveland in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. Fanta explains why he picked the Knicks in six, why the Cavs “lost their souls” in the fourth quarter, and why Cleveland fans saw the collapse coming. The guys also dive into Donovan Mitchell, Kenny Atkinson’s coaching decisions, Jalen Brunson’s dominance, Karl-Anthony Towns needing to step up, and whether this is finally the Knicks’ year to win a championship.

Chris McMonigle and the crew discuss Matt Martin’s transition from the NHL and his humorous relationship with Islanders teammates Casey Cizikas and Cal Clutterbuck. They also share personal stories about bowling achievements and perform a comedic inspection of Pete Hoffman's unusually large knees.

01:00 - Sushi vs. Sashimi

02:35 - Matt Martin Discussion

05:18 - Bowling and Knees

Craig Carton describes a memorable encounter with Islanders owner John Ledecky at the Delta Club. Chris McMonigle discusses the unique seating experience at Madison Square Garden and compares running styles to Keyser Söze.

01:00 - Quarters And Racing

03:50 - MSG Ticket Prices

09:14 - Ledecky's Sushi Manners

Craig Carton recounts a miserable morning dealing with food poisoning and a helpful workplace encounter with a custodian named Yusuf. They discuss the recent exposure of Oz Pearlman's mentalism tricks by Pablo Torre and Dan Le Batard. Mac then reveals the secrets behind his signature card-in-orange magic trick that once stunned Ray Rice's mother.

01:00 - Craig's Stomach Issues

06:32 - Sciazzaro Wedding Snub

08:08 - Oz Pearlman Debunked

13:45 - Magic Orange Trick

18:10 - Big Snow American Dream

Craig and Chris analyze the Mets' struggles and whether fans should buy into their recent tease of a win streak. They explore the myths of baseball history, including Juan Soto's home run and Babe Ruth's famous called shot. The conversation shifts to a celebrity basketball story before a heated exchange with a Cleveland Cavaliers fan named Greg.

01:00 - Mets Rebuilding Struggles

06:41 - Strip Club Analogy

08:35 - Soto and Babe Ruth

14:21 - John Wallace Basketball

17:31 - Cavs Fan Trash Talk