The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Knicks' incredible 22-point comeback and discuss Jalen Brunson's surging legacy. They also rip into the New York Mets for the Gary Carter jersey blunder and react to Aaron Rodgers' retirement news. Additionally, they debate movie sequels and the conflict of rooting for family versus a favorite team.

01:20 - Knicks Comeback and Mets Grand Slam

05:08 - Mets Disrespect Gary Carter's Legacy

13:53 - Aaron Rodgers Announces Final Season

17:35 - Leon Rose's Impact on the Knicks

21:58 - Tom Thibodeau's Legacy and Success

29:15 - Big Mac’s Custom Board Game Business

34:30 - Watching Knicks with a Bat Infestation

38:59 - Debating the Greatest Movie Sequels

51:30 - Rooting for Family vs. Favorite Team

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle celebrate Boomer Esiason's induction into the National Radio Hall of Fame while reflecting on their history together. They also break down Jalen Brunson’s historic performance in the Knicks' comeback win and discuss the impact of ALS following a moving call from a listener.

01:20 - Zach Thornton’s Mets Debut

04:40 - Aaron Rodgers Retirement Tour

08:08 - Ayahuasca and Sports Discussion

13:40 - WFAN History and Grievances

18:52 - Tommy’s ALS Diagnosis Call

25:38 - Knicks’ Historic Comeback Win

32:24 - Roasting Station Employee Attire

36:30 - Boomer's Hall of Fame Honor

45:01 - Afternoon Sports Roundup

Craig and Chris give a heart felt tribute to Boomer Esiason after it was announced he would be inducted into the Radio Hall of Fame

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle spiral into an all-time movie debate on The Carton Show after talking Knicks, bats flying around houses during playoff games, and kids bringing Yankees hats to school.

Craig unloads on legendary sequels like Ghostbusters 2, Jaws 2, Ace Ventura 2, Back to the Future 2, and even Die Hard With a Vengeance while the rest of the studio calls his movie opinions completely insane.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to one of the strangest Mets controversies in years after the team accidentally gave away Gary Carter’s iconic No. 8 jersey.

After the Knicks’ unbelievable playoff comeback at Madison Square Garden, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails in this hilarious Carton Show segment.

The Knicks pulled off another unbelievable playoff comeback at Madison Square Garden, and Craig Carton is ready to give Mike Brown ALL the credit. Craig and Chris McMonigle debate Brown’s coaching adjustments, Landry Shamet’s huge impact, Tom Thibodeau comparisons, and whether the Knicks are officially headed to the NBA Finals. Plus: Craig stirs the pot ranking the best coaches and executives in New York sports right now.

A caller shares wit Carton & Big Mac how he refused to leave the toilet for 25 minutes to ensure a Knicks victory, leading to a debate over bathroom-related health risks. They jokingly discuss which colleague is most likely to meet an end like Elvis and delve into the intricacies of newspaper obituaries and leper colony legends.

01:00 - Laughing At Evan Roberts

04:51 - Ben's Bathroom Superstition

05:56 - Bathroom Hazards And Obituaries

The New York Knicks completed a 22-point comeback to defeat the Cleveland Cavaliers in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. Discussions cover Jalen Brunson's heroics, Karl-Anthony Towns' mistakes, the Mets' jersey controversy, and a ritual involving an Aztec death whistle.

01:01 - Knicks Comeback Victory

04:51 - NBA Performance Comparisons

09:09 - Mets and Death Whistle

Big Mac breaks down the New York Knicks' improbable 22-point comeback victory over the Cleveland Cavaliers at Madison Square Garden. He praises Jalen Brunson's superstar performance and the crucial coaching adjustments made down the stretch. They also criticize fans who left the game early and address the New York Mets' blunder regarding Gary Carter's jersey number.

01:08 - Knicks Historic Comeback

08:01 - Early Exit Fan Critique

11:51 - Mets Gary Carter Blunder

17:25 - Brunson Performance Analysis

21:31 - Madison Square Garden Chaos