The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Big Mac analyzes the Mets' surprising success in the Subway Series while highlighting the Yankees' recent pitching and roster concerns. They also explore Eli Manning’s candid explanation for avoiding the Chargers and discuss Jalen Brunson’s legacy as the Knicks prepare for the Eastern Conference Finals.

01:20 - Subway Series Breakdown

06:15 - Aaron Boone Critique

10:35 - Movies And Personal Stories

25:20 - Manning's Chargers Draft Truth

30:43 - Brunson's Knick Legacy

34:21 - Eastern Conference Finals Preview

40:27 - Knicks vs Nets Rivalry

C-Mac analyzes the Mets' recent success over the Yankees and how the series highlighted major issues within the Bronx Bombers' bullpen. He offers a strong defense of Aaron Boone’s managerial choices before the conversation shifts into humorous territory with stories of childhood antics and cable bill mishaps.

01:00 - MLB Roster Updates

02:41 - Subway Series Recap

06:08 - Defending Aaron Boone

09:35 - Movie Comparison Debate

15:05 - Cable Bill Stories

While Craig is away Chris & the Crew explore Ben Simmons' transition into professional competitive fishing and his ownership in the South Florida Sails. A caller recounts a chance dinner meeting with Paul McCartney, describing the rock legend's surprising humility and kindness. The discussion also highlights the high-stakes world of elite sport fishing, including Michael Jordan's involvement.

01:00 - Knicks Banners and Fishing

05:51 - Ben Simmons Pro Fishing

10:40 - Meeting Paul McCartney

13:16 - Pro Fishing Tournament Scene

Big Mac is flying solo and discusses the potential return of Yankees ace Gerrit Cole and NBA player Ben Simmons' victory in a professional saltwater fishing league. The segment also covers the Mets' roster adjustments following key injuries and includes listener calls regarding recent performances from both New York teams.

01:00 - Gerrit Cole's Potential Return

05:01 - Mets Roster Moves

12:01 - Bullpen Strategy and Calls

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman analyze Aaron Rodgers' return to the Steelers and the viral story of Howie Rose leaving a Mets game to meet Paul McCartney. They compare the legacy of the 1986 Mets to the current Knicks squad while debating the team's chances in the upcoming series against the Cavaliers.

01:32 - Aaron Rodgers Steelers Return

04:07 - Howie Rose Meets McCartney

13:05 - Knicks Playoff Analysis

19:10 - Caller Accent Banter

Big Mac opens by congratulating Anthony Gallo on his recent engagement and sharing lighthearted wedding planning advice on The Carton Show. They transition to New York Yankees news, discussing roster moves and the anticipated return of Gerrit Cole to the rotation. The segment concludes with an in-depth preview of the New York Knicks' upcoming playoff series against the Cleveland Cavaliers.

01:00 - Anthony Gallo Engagement

07:33 - Yankees Roster Moves

13:40 - Subway Series Analysis

17:38 - Yankees Lineup Changes

21:48 - Knicks Playoff Preview

Chris McMonigle reacts to broadcaster Joe Davis's viral "Oh, the Mets" call, debating whether national announcers are biased against New York teams. They also celebrate Michael Kay's use of the term "five and fly" and evaluate the Yankees' decision to sign Yovanny Cruz to bolster the bullpen.

01:00 - Joe Davis Mocking Mets

08:01 - Subway Series Recap

09:47 - Five and Fly Vindication

13:22 - Knicks Playoff Path

16:34 - Yankees Sign Yovanny Cruz

Chris McMonigle examines the fallout from the Subway Series, noting how the Mets' performance crystallized the systemic issues facing the Yankees. He evaluates the struggles of Austin Wells and the bullpen while discussing potential roster adjustments and the impact of recent injuries.

01:00 - Journey and The Sopranos

03:08 - Mets Sweep Subway Series

09:34 - Yankees Roster and Bullpen

13:07 - The Crystallized Word Debate

19:25 - Mets Injuries and Vibes

Chris McMonigle is riding solo today, discussing the Mets' resilient performance in the Subway Series following a rotation injury. He evaluates the Yankees' bullpen struggles and roster gaps while looking ahead to the Knicks' playoff series against the Cavaliers.

01:03 - Big Mac Flying Solo

01:53 - Mets Subway Series Mojo

10:29 - Yankees Bullpen Meltdown

18:01 - Yankees Offensive Struggles

20:06 - Knicks Vs Cavs Preview

Hear from New York legends Walt ‘Clyde’ Frazier (0:00), Mariano Rivera (48:00), Al Leiter (1:05:19) and Yankees podcasters Jake Storiale and Joez McFly (1:26:13)