The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

They revisit early-season radio clips of Howie Rose and Keith Raad praising the New York Mets' offensive approach, contrasting those predictions with the team's dismal reality. The conversation also explores the disputed history of Abner Doubleday and sparks a debate over whether legendary broadcasters should return for on-field ceremonies after retirement.

01:29 - Abner Doubleday History

03:16 - Mocking Early Mets Predictions

14:14 - David Stearns Injury Issues

17:36 - Howie Rose Retirement Debate

David Stearns faces tough questions from Joel Sherman regarding the future of Carlos Mendoza and the organization's underperformance. They also dive into a heated debate about K-Swiss sneakers' place in hip-hop culture, featuring a call-in from Big Hurls and a surprising text from Lil Wayne.

01:20 - Stearns Confronts Mendoza Questions

04:57 - The Mets Irrelevance Problem

09:43 - NFL Global Schedule Leaks

14:02 - Doubleday Myths And Florida NY

17:27 - Black Dirt Farming Secrets

20:55 - K-Swiss Hip Hop Debate

24:22 - Big Hurls Defends K-Swiss

30:37 - Amish Builders And Jersey Shore

A heated debate erupts over the legitimacy of K-Swiss in hip-hop culture, prompting a call from Big Hurls to school everyone on his rap credentials. They also examine the myth of Abner Doubleday and the unique agricultural output of Florida, New York.

01:00 - Abner Doubleday Myth

02:40 - Florida New York Onions

08:06 - K-Swiss Hip-Hop Debate

13:01 - Big Hurls Rap Battle

18:38 - New York Sports Update

David Stearns faces pointed questions from Joel Sherman about the job security of Carlos Mendoza as the Mets struggle to stay relevant. Discussion highlights the team's current state by noting how even dedicated fans are losing track of the starting rotation. The segment covers leaked details of NFL games in Madrid and Paris before debating the best scrambled egg techniques.

01:00 - Stearns Defends Carlos Mendoza

04:22 - Mets Falling into Irrelevance

07:48 - NFL International Schedule Leaks

11:15 - Perfecting Scrambled Egg Methods

They dissect the New York Mets' disappointing season, contrasting early-season broadcast optimism with the reality of the team's current performance. The discussion also explores the historical myth of Abner Doubleday and debates whether retiring legends like Howie Rose should return for team ceremonies.

01:00 - Abner Doubleday Origin Myth

03:11 - Critiquing Mets Season Hype

12:31 - Mets Roster and Injury Updates

17:50 - Howie Rose Retirement Debate

Discussion focuses on the perceived scam of modern youth baseball gear, ranging from sliding mitts to expensive customized bats. A historical argument breaks out over whether Abner Doubleday actually invented baseball or if it was Alexander Cartwright. They also engage in a heated debate on the coolness of K-Swiss sneakers and critique Ken Burns' documentary style.

01:00 - Youth Baseball Gear Critique

09:27 - K-Swiss Style Debate

14:34 - Anthony Volpe Roster Status

16:21 - Abner Doubleday Invention Mystery

21:00 - Ken Burns Documentary Critique

They discuss breaking news regarding the New York Yankees as Anthony Volpe is called up to replace an injured Jose Caballero. The conversation highlights the debate surrounding Volpe's readiness given his recent minor league struggles and the pressure of joining a team in a four-game slump.

01:00 - Breaking Yankees News

02:54 - Volpe Gets The Call

08:35 - Evaluating Volpe's Performance

13:32 - Fan Reaction To Volpe

21:10 - Volpe's Arrival Status

Craig and Big Mac explore a strange story about Donald Trump insisting Chris Christie eat the White House meatloaf during a private dinner. They also analyze the controversy surrounding Disney cruises and address a caller's concerns about Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s batting slump. The discussion touches on Thanksgiving food preferences and the prestige of visiting the White House as a champion.

01:31 - MLB Event & Disney Cruises

06:36 - Donald Trump Knicks Fan

08:15 - Christie's White House Meatloaf

13:37 - Thanksgiving Food Debate

15:37 - Jazz Chisholm Jr. Slump

Big Mac considers a potential studio visit from Rich Robinson before examining the tragic career of Otis Redding and the "deal with the devil" music theory. They analyze the Mets' trajectory toward a 100-loss season and debate Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s maturity following a rough performance for the Yankees. The conversation also explores humorous personal habits like whistling on the toilet to avoid family stress and a lunch review of sandwiches from Faicco's.

01:04 - Rich Robinson Studio Visit

04:13 - Otis Redding History

08:14 - Mets Relevance Crisis

11:41 - Bathroom Hiding Habits

18:24 - Jazz Chisholm Maturity Debate

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' recent four-game skid and the offensive disappearing act of Jazz Chisholm Jr. They also discuss the lack of leaks surrounding the New York Jets' schedule compared to other NFL teams. The conversation shifts to the New York Mets' struggles under David Stearns before concluding with personal banter and a featured segment on grilling with Premio sausage.

01:05 - Carton Show Intro

02:47 - NFL Schedule Leaks

06:40 - Yankees Slump Analysis

09:06 - Jazz Chisholm Jr. Struggles

20:23 - Mets Opening Struggles