The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig and Big Mac discuss the growing tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone regarding Judge's calf injury and wild-card availability. They also analyze the New York Giants' outlook after a season-ending injury to the starting quarterback and compare local rosters.

(00:02:42) Judge Boone Injury Conflict

(00:11:10) Kuzmenko Father Bear Attack

(00:16:41) Hostin Juror Story Fraud

(00:21:23) Giants Jets Roster Debate

(00:25:11) Teaching Gallo Bike Riding

(00:31:03) Tebow Charity Allegations

Craig and Big Mac analyze the tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone over the captain's calf injury and playoff status. They debate whether Judge’s secrecy regarding his health is selfish while also comparing his injury history to Giancarlo Stanton's frequent setbacks. The conversation shifts to Craig’s viral banana video, a fact-check of Sonny Hostin, and a radio ratings prank.

(00:01:20) Weather And Sports Updates

(00:04:45) Judge And Boone Tension

(00:08:58) Judge Playoff Roster Debate

(00:13:45) Viral Content And Urlacher

(00:17:00) Sonny Hostin Jury Lie

(00:20:48) Judge Injury History Debate

(00:25:15) Judge Versus Stanton Comparison

(00:30:45) Radio Ratings Prank Story

Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Morgan Wallen received zero CMA nominations before diving into the New York Giants' injury crisis. They debate the team's viability with Jameis Winston and criticize Kurt Warner for his comments regarding Jayden Daniels' toughness. The duo also discusses a bizarre hockey tragedy and mocks Gallo for his inability to ride a bicycle.

(00:01:20) Morgan Wallen Snub

(00:05:30) Giants Injury Updates

(00:09:30) Giants Season Debate

(00:14:45) Kurt Warner Comments

(00:10:50) Andrei Kuzmenko Tragedy

(00:14:20) Shaka Salamander Revenge

(00:19:45) Madden Movie Trailer

(00:23:00) Gallo Bicycle Mockery

Craig Carton and Big Mac debate why the Jets currently boast a superior roster over the Giants following the injury to Jaxson Dart. They blast the NFL for imposing heavy fines on celebratory demonstrations while simultaneously promoting alcohol and gambling sponsors. The discussion also covers Yankees postseason updates and a high-stakes bet regarding New York football supremacy.

(00:01:20) Teaching Big Mac to Bike

(00:04:15) Jets vs. Giants Roster Debate

(00:08:50) Criticizing New York Football Coaching

(00:14:45) Ridiculous NFL Celebration Fines

(00:18:05) Yankees Weather and Stanton News

(00:21:25) High-Stakes Win Total Bet

(00:23:55) New York's Best Bagel Spots

(00:26:50) Big Mac's Weight Loss Journey

The crew analyzes the plummeting ticket prices for the upcoming New York Giants game and evaluates potential quarterback replacements after Jaxson Dart's injury. They also critique the state of NFL pregame shows and defend Tim Tebow against recent investigative allegations.

(00:01:20) Falcons Primetime Woes

(00:04:20) Giants Ticket Price Analysis

(00:10:29) Giants Quarterback Future

(00:15:15) NFL Media Show Critique

(00:19:43) NBA Personal Life Controversies

(00:28:31) Tim Tebow Charity Investigation

(00:16:29) Jaxson Dart Injury Status

(00:22:40) Strange Culinary Discussions

(00:26:56) Iconic Football Moments

McMonigle (Big Mac) analyzes the devastating impact of Jaxson Dart's season-ending injury on the New York Giants and the team's pivot to Jameis Winston. He also discusses the New York Yankees' postseason pitching rotation and the upcoming CC Sabathia number retirement ceremony.

(00:03:44) Giants Season Without Dart

(00:10:52) Yankees Doubleheader Update

(00:14:20) Yankees Rotation Dilemma

(00:17:44) Hall of Fame Debate

(00:15:53) Big Mac NFL Picks

Gregg Popovich’s marriage to the ex-wife of his former assistant sparks a debate over social etiquette and the ‘guy code.’ They also dive into rock history with surprising facts about the Beatles and Eric Clapton. The conversation shifts to defending Tim Tebow’s character following investigative reports from Pablo Torre regarding charitable ties.

(00:01:17) Packers Injury Problems

(00:02:00) Popovich Marries Budenholzer's Ex

(00:06:43) Beatles Facts And Gossip

(00:10:50) Torre Investigates Tim Tebow

(00:17:47) Yankees And Judge Update

Carton and the crew analyze the fallout from Jaxson Dart's injury and the impact on New York Giants ticket prices, which have plummeted for the upcoming Titans matchup. They explore potential quarterback replacements like Jimmy Garoppolo and critique the current state of NFL pregame shows.

(00:01:00) Falcons Primetime Scheduling Issues

(00:04:32) Giants Ticket Prices Plummet

(00:11:34) Jaxson Dart Injury Concerns

(00:14:13) Giants Quarterback Search

(00:16:19) Critiquing The NFL Today

A heated debate breaks out on WFAN regarding whether the Jets or Giants currently possess a better roster following key injuries. They also critique John Harbaugh's recent coaching performance and analyze the Giants' chances of reaching seven wins with a backup quarterback.

(00:01:05) Learning To Ride A Bike

(00:03:46) Jets Vs Giants Roster Debate

(00:07:47) Giants Backup QB Outlook

(00:08:59) John Harbaugh Coaching Critique

(00:14:37) Yankees Wild Card Concerns

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a bizarre report regarding Andrei Kuzmenko’s father before Carton recounts a childhood revenge story involving his pet salamander. They also critique Nicolas Cage’s performance as John Madden and debate the future of the New York Giants season.

(00:01:00) Andrei Kuzmenko Bear Story

(00:04:33) Revenge for the Salamander

(00:06:49) Nicolas Cage John Madden

(00:09:45) Gallo's Biking Struggles

(00:14:20) Giants Quarterback Concerns