The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

The Yankees' offense is struggling again, and Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton have had enough. The guys debate Jazz Chisholm's disastrous season at the plate, why expectations are so much higher for Jazz, and whether Ben Rice has also fallen off after carrying the Yankees earlier this season.

The Yankees' pitching keeps giving them a chance, but the offense continues to let them down. Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down New York's brutal 1-0 loss to the Mariners, the Yankees managing just FOUR hits, and why Jazz Chisholm is becoming a major problem at the plate.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the Giants wide receiver room and if it's good enough. What's the easiest path for the Yankees to get back to the World Series? How much better will the Jets be? Should the Knicks be scared of the LeBron James led 76ers?

Craig says the Giants are lacking strong skill position players outside Malik Nabers. The Yankees squeak out a win despite continued offensive struggles. The Lakers get sold once again. Craig has an idea for a new website.

Gallo is back from vacation and Craig and C-Mac can't believe how little he knows about famous actors. Is it weird to get a massage for your prostate? Niko, filling in for Hoff, is throwing his own birthday party.

Craig thinks the jets are capable of being a near .500 team. C-Mac believes Aaron Glenn has been humbled which is a good thing. Russell Westbrook announces his retirement from the NBA. Is he a first ballot hall of famer? Should the Knicks fear the Sixers?

Stu Feiner calls in and predicts that both the Giants and Jets will beat their respective win totals.

Russell Westbrook has officially retired after an incredible 18-year NBA career, and Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle debate where he ranks among the greatest players of his generation. From averaging a triple-double for a season to becoming an MVP and future first-ballot Hall of Famer, the guys break down why Westbrook's legacy deserves more respect.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to Aaron Glenn’s latest interview and both admit they feel MUCH better about the Jets head coach heading into the 2026 season.

After a disastrous first season, Glenn appears to be embracing his strengths as a defensive coach and taking ownership of the mistakes he made. Carton says Glenn came across as confident, comfortable and genuine, while Big Mac admits he went home thinking about the interview and came away impressed.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle have a hilarious conversation about producer Nico’s REAL first name and the reveal leads to an all-out roast!

Then Anthony Gallo walks into the studio and immediately gets put to the test on movies, actors, and classic books. From Robert Redford to Gary Sinise, The Natural, The Deer Hunter, Of Mice and Men and more, Carton and Big Mac discover just how little Gallo remembers!